54215310
A line \(\ell\) and a point \(P\) not on \(\ell\) are given. A student uses this digital construction sequence:
1. Create line \(m\) through \(P\) perpendicular to \(\ell\).
2. Choose point \(Q\) on \(m\), with \(Q\ne P\).
3. Create line \(n\) through \(Q\) perpendicular to \(m\).
The student claims that \(n\) is the required line parallel to \(\ell\) through \(P\).
a) Is \(n\) parallel to \(\ell\)? Justify your answer.
b) Does \(n\) satisfy the full construction requirement? Explain.
c) State the single change that repairs the sequence.
Hints
- Separate the direction requirement from the point-of-passage requirement.
- Compare how each of the two relevant lines relates to the same third line.
- Check the point named in the final construction step.
Solution
1. Line \(m\) is perpendicular to \(\ell\), and line \(n\) is also perpendicular to \(m\).
2. Two coplanar lines perpendicular to the same line are parallel, so \(n\parallel\ell\).
3. Line \(n\) passes through \(Q\), not through \(P\), so it does not satisfy the requirement that the parallel line pass through \(P\).
4. In step 3, the perpendicular to \(m\) must be created through \(P\) rather than through \(Q\).
Answer
a) Yes. Both \(n\) and \(\ell\) are perpendicular to \(m\), so \(n\parallel\ell\).
b) No. It is parallel to \(\ell\), but it does not pass through \(P\).
c) Create the second perpendicular through \(P\), not through \(Q\).
