Points \(A\) and \(B\) lie on a circle, and point \(P\) lies outside the circle. Consider the statement: “If \(\overline{PA}\) and \(\overline{PB}\) are tangent segments, then \(PA=PB\).”
a) Write the converse.
b) Is the converse true? Give a counterexample.
c) Write the contrapositive of the original statement.
Hints
- Reverse the hypothesis and conclusion while keeping the stated circle context fixed.
- Look for two equal segments from an external point to points on a circle that are not tangent.
- Reverse and negate both parts to form the contrapositive.
Solution
1. The converse is: if \(PA=PB\), then \(\overline{PA}\) and \(\overline{PB}\) are tangent segments.
2. The converse is false. For example, use the unit circle centered at \(O(0, 0)\), let \(P(2, 0)\), \(A(0, 1)\), and \(B(0, -1)\). Then \(P\) is outside the circle and \(PA=PB=\sqrt{5}\).
3. However, neither \(\overline{PA}\) nor \(\overline{PB}\) is perpendicular to the radius at its endpoint, so neither segment is tangent.
4. The contrapositive is: if \(PA\ne PB\), then \(\overline{PA}\) and \(\overline{PB}\) are not both tangent segments.
Answer
a) If \(PA=PB\), then \(\overline{PA}\) and \(\overline{PB}\) are tangent segments.
b) False. On the unit circle, take \(P(2, 0)\), \(A(0, 1)\), and \(B(0, -1)\). Then \(PA=PB=\sqrt{5}\), but the segments are not tangent.
c) If \(PA\ne PB\), then the two segments are not both tangent segments.