In triangle \(ABC\), \(M\) is the midpoint of \(\overline{BC}\), and \(AM=\frac{1}{2}BC\). A student labels the following argument an indirect proof that \(\angle A=90^\circ\):
“Assume \(\angle A\ne90^\circ\). Since \(BM=CM=\frac{1}{2}BC\), we have \(AM=BM=CM\). Thus \(A\), \(B\), and \(C\) lie on a circle centered at \(M\), and \(BC\) is a diameter. Therefore, \(\angle A=90^\circ\), contradicting the assumption.”
a) Is the argument logically valid? Explain why it is not a well-designed indirect proof.
b) Rewrite it so the contradiction assumption does essential work.

Hints
- Check whether each intermediate statement depends on the opening assumption.
- A redundant contradiction assumption can be removed without changing a direct proof.
- To make the assumption useful, apply the contrapositive of the diameter-angle theorem before using the equal distances from \(M\).
Solution
1. The argument is logically valid, but the assumption \(\angle A\ne90^\circ\) is not used to derive any intermediate fact. Deleting the assumption and the final contradiction leaves a complete direct proof.
2. For a genuine indirect proof, assume \(\angle A\ne90^\circ\).
3. By the contrapositive of the theorem that an angle subtending a diameter is a right angle, point \(A\) cannot lie on the circle with diameter \(\overline{BC}\).
4. Since \(M\) is the midpoint of \(BC\), \(BM=CM=\frac{1}{2}BC\). The given condition also gives \(AM=\frac{1}{2}BC\).
5. Therefore, \(AM=BM=CM\), so \(A\), \(B\), and \(C\) lie on the circle centered at \(M\).
6. Because \(M\) lies on \(BC\), segment \(\overline{BC}\) is a diameter of that circle. Thus \(A\) does lie on the circle with diameter \(\overline{BC}\), contradicting Step 3.
7. Hence \(\angle A=90^\circ\).
Answer
a) The argument is logically valid, but it is a direct proof with an unused contradiction assumption: the circle-and-diameter reasoning proves \(\angle A=90^\circ\) without the first sentence.
b) Assume \(\angle A\ne90^\circ\). Then, by the contrapositive of the diameter-angle theorem, \(A\) is not on the circle with diameter \(BC\). But \(AM=BM=CM\) places \(A\), \(B\), and \(C\) on the circle centered at \(M\), whose diameter is \(BC\). This contradiction proves \(\angle A=90^\circ\).