Panels a) and b) show the first six partial sums \(S_n\) of two infinite geometric series. Both series have first term \(4\), and their common ratios are \(1\) and \(-1\), one ratio for each panel. The panels are not identified with the ratios.
a) Match each panel to its common ratio.
b) For each panel, describe the pattern of \(S_n\) with a formula or odd-even rule and explain why the corresponding infinite series diverges.
c) Explain how the two graphs illustrate what can happen at the boundary \(|r|=1\).

Hints
- Read the sequence of plotted partial sums before deciding which ratio belongs to each panel.
- Consecutive differences of partial sums recover the terms of the underlying series.
- Compare what the partial sums do as \(n\) increases: approach one value, grow, or oscillate.
- Relate both behaviors to the strict convergence condition \(|r|<1\).
Solution
1. Panel a) has partial sums \(4,8,12,16,20,24\). Their consecutive differences are all \(4\), so every series term is \(4\) and the common ratio is \(r=1\).
2. For panel a), \(S_n=4n\), so the partial sums grow without bound and the infinite series diverges.
3. Panel b) has partial sums \(4,0,4,0,4,0\). The corresponding terms are \(4,-4,4,-4,\ldots\), so the common ratio is \(r=-1\).
4. For panel b), \(S_n=4\) for odd \(n\) and \(S_n=0\) for even \(n\). The partial sums oscillate and do not approach a single value, so the infinite series diverges.
5. Both examples have \(|r|=1\), showing two different forms of divergence at the boundary of the geometric-series convergence condition \(|r|<1\).
Answer
a) Panel a): \(r=1\); panel b): \(r=-1\).
b) Panel a): \(S_n=4n\), so the partial sums grow without bound. Panel b): \(S_n=4\) for odd \(n\) and \(S_n=0\) for even \(n\), so the partial sums oscillate. Both series diverge.
c) At \(|r|=1\), partial sums need not approach a finite limit: they may grow without bound or oscillate.