53093112
Assume that birth months are independent and that each of the \(12\) months is equally likely.
a) Find the probability that at least two people in a randomly formed group of \(4\) share a birth month.
b) Find the smallest group size \(n\) for which the probability of at least one shared birth month is greater than \(50\%\).
c) In a group of \(5\), an opponent wins \(\$5\) from you if at least two people share a birth month. You win \(\$5\) if all birth months are different. Determine whether the game is fair.
Hints
- Use the complement that all birth months are different.
- Check group sizes in increasing order.
- A fair game has expected net gain \(0\).
Solution
1. For \(4\) people, \(P(\text{all different})=\frac{12\cdot11\cdot10\cdot9}{12^4}=\frac{55}{96}\approx 0.57292\). Thus, \(P(\text{at least one match})=1-\frac{55}{96}=\frac{41}{96}\approx 0.42708\).
2. For \(5\) people, \(P(\text{all different})=\frac{12\cdot11\cdot10\cdot9\cdot8}{12^5}=\frac{55}{144}\approx 0.38194\), so the match probability is \(\frac{89}{144}\approx 0.61806\). Since the probability for \(4\) people is below \(0.5\), the smallest value is \(n=5\).
3. Your expected net gain is \(5\left(\frac{55}{144}\right)-5\left(\frac{89}{144}\right)=-\frac{85}{72}\approx -\$1.18\). The game is not fair and favors the opponent.
Answer
a) \(\frac{41}{96}\approx 0.42708\)
b) \(n=5\)
c) The game is not fair. Your expected net gain is approximately \(-\$1.18\) per play.
