A school fair has four cards that pay \(\$0\), \(\$2\), \(\$6\), or \(\$8\). A student pays \(\$4\) to play. The four cards are shuffled, and one is drawn equally likely.
After seeing the first card, the student may keep its prize or pay another \(\$1\) to draw one of the three remaining cards equally likely. If the student draws again, the second prize replaces the first.
a) For each possible first prize, decide whether keeping it or drawing again gives the higher expected net gain.
b) If the student always makes the better choice, what is the expected net gain for one play?
Hints
- After one card is seen, which possible prizes remain available?
- For a particular first prize, which choice has a better average return after any extra cost?
- Could the best decision change depending on the first card?
- How likely is each possible first card before the student starts playing?
Solution
1. The original \(\$4\) fee is paid either way. After a first prize of \(\$0\), redrawing gives an expected payout of \(\frac{2+6+8}{3}=\frac{16}{3}\), with an extra \(\$1\) fee. Drawing again is better than keeping \(\$0\).
2. After \(\$2\), the expected redraw payout is \(\frac{0+6+8}{3}=\frac{14}{3}\). After the extra fee this is worth \(\frac{11}{3}\), which is greater than keeping \(\$2\).
3. After \(\$6\), redrawing gives \(\frac{0+2+8}{3}-1=\frac{7}{3}\), less than keeping \(\$6\). After \(\$8\), redrawing gives \(\frac{0+2+6}{3}-1=\frac{5}{3}\), less than keeping \(\$8\). Keep either of these prizes.
4. After the original \(\$4\) fee, the four possible first cards give conditional expected net gains of \(\frac{1}{3}\), \(-\frac{1}{3}\), \(2\), and \(4\) dollars under the better choices.
5. Each first card has probability \(\frac{1}{4}\). The expected net gain is \(\frac{1}{4}\left(\frac{1}{3}-\frac{1}{3}+2+4\right)=\frac{3}{2}\) dollars.
Answer
a) Draw again after \(\$0\) or \(\$2\); keep \(\$6\) or \(\$8\).
b) Expected net gain: \(\$1.50\) per play.