Aimathic
Login | English | Deutsch

Precalculus math worksheets

Build your own math worksheets from 35,000+ problems for grades 3 to 12, from fractions to AP Calculus. Every problem comes with step-by-step solutions.

Permutations with repeated elements

Learning goals

  • Recognizes when repeated indistinguishable elements reduce the number of distinct arrangements.
  • Uses factorial division to account for repeated elements.
  • Finds the number of arrangements with repeated elements.
  • Explains the source of overcounting in the unrestricted factorial count.

Click problems to add them to your worksheet.

Permutations with repeated elements 1
In an arrangement of the symbols \(A,A,B,C\), does swapping the two A's create a new distinct arrangement? Answer yes or no and state the overcounting factor caused by the repeated A's.

Hints

- Compare what the arrangement looks like before and after exchanging the two identical symbols. - Ask how many orders the two copies of A would have if they were temporarily labeled.

Solution

1. No. The two A's are identical, so exchanging them does not change the visible arrangement. 2. Treating them as distinct would count each visible arrangement \(2!\) times.

Answer

No; the overcounting factor is \(2!\).
Permutations with repeated elements 2
For the symbols \(M,M,A,A\), which expression counts the distinct arrangements: \(4!\), \(\frac{4!}{2!}\), or \(\frac{4!}{2!\,2!}\)?

Hints

- Identify every symbol that occurs more than once. - Each repeated group creates its own overcounting factor.

Solution

1. There are two identical M's and two identical A's. 2. Correct for both repeated groups, so the appropriate expression is \(\frac{4!}{2!\,2!}\).

Answer

\(\frac{4!}{2!\,2!}\)
Permutations with repeated elements 3
Arrange the letters A, A, B, B in a row, using every letter once. Swapping identical letters does not make a new arrangement. List all distinct arrangements. How many are there?

Hints

- Begin with one fixed first letter and list the different ways to complete the row. - Repeat with the other first letter. - Check whether swapping the two identical A's creates a new arrangement.

Solution

1. Start with AA, which gives AABB, or end with AA, which gives BBAA. 2. The remaining arrangements are ABAB, ABBA, BAAB, and BABA. 3. There are \(6\) distinct arrangements. Swapping the two A's or the two B's cannot create another one.

Answer

AABB, ABAB, ABBA, BAAB, BABA, BBAA; \(6\) arrangements.
Permutations with repeated elements 4
Two identical red tiles lie in a row next to a blue tile. Noor and Felix sit in two seats next to each other. Does swapping the two red tiles create a new color pattern? Does Noor switching seats with Felix create a new seating arrangement? Explain.

Hints

- What information defines a tile color pattern? - What information defines where named students sit?

Solution

1. The red tiles look the same in the color pattern, so swapping them does not change the pattern. 2. Noor and Felix are different people, so switching their seats does change which person occupies each position.

Answer

Red tiles: no new pattern. Noor and Felix: a different seating arrangement, because their positions are distinguishable.
Permutations with repeated elements 5
Four squares form a row. One is orange and the other three are blue. Squares of the same color are identical. How many different color patterns are possible? Explain how the orange square's position tells you the count without listing every pattern.

Hints

- Which square makes one pattern different from another? - After you place the orange square, can moving the blue squares change the pattern?

Solution

1. The orange square can be in position \(1\), \(2\), \(3\), or \(4\). 2. Once its position is chosen, all the other squares are blue, so there are no more choices. 3. There are \(4\) patterns.

Answer

\(4\) patterns, one for each possible position of the orange square.
Permutations with repeated elements 6
Lina lays beads in a straight row, read from left to right. Reversing the row counts as a different order if the colors appear in a different sequence. a) She has three beads: one red, one green, and one blue. How many different orders can she make? b) Now she uses four beads: two identical red beads and two identical blue beads. How many orders are possible if the first bead must be red?

Hints

- For part a, count the permutations of three distinct objects. - In part b, treat the first red bead as fixed. - How many distinct orders can be made from one red bead and two identical blue beads?

Solution

a) The three distinct beads can be arranged in \(3!=6\) orders. b) Fix one red bead in the first position. The remaining beads are one red and two identical blue beads, so the number of distinct arrangements is \(\frac{3!}{2!}=3\).

Answer

a) \(6\) arrangements b) \(3\) arrangements
Permutations with repeated elements 7
A three-digit code is formed from specified digits. a) How many different codes can be formed using the digits \(1,2,\) and \(3\) exactly once each? b) How many different codes can be formed using the digits \(1,1,\) and \(2\)? List them all.

Hints

- How many permutations are possible when all three digits are distinct? - For part b, list the codes in increasing order. - Why do two identical digits reduce the number of distinct arrangements?

Solution

a) Three distinct digits can be arranged in \(3!=6\) orders. b) For the multiset \(\{1,1,2\}\), divide by the \(2!\) arrangements of the identical \(1\)s: \(\frac{3!}{2!}=3\). The codes are \(112\), \(121\), and \(211\).

Answer

a) \(6\) codes b) \(3\) codes: \(112,121,211\)
Permutations with repeated elements 8
How many distinct arrangements of the letters in the word LEVEL are possible?

Hints

- Count the total number of letters and identify which letters repeat. - Swapping two identical copies does not create a new arrangement. - Account separately for each group of repeated letters.

Solution

1. LEVEL has \(5\) letters, with \(2\) identical L's and \(2\) identical E's. 2. Start with \(5!\) arrangements and divide by \(2!\) for the repeated L's and by \(2!\) for the repeated E's: \(\frac{5!}{2!\,2!}=30\).

Answer

\(30\) distinct arrangements
Permutations with repeated elements 9
Six letter tiles, M, M, N, N, P, and P, are placed in a row. The first tile must be P. How many distinct arrangements are possible?

Hints

- Fix the required first tile before arranging the others. - Which letters are still repeated? - How many labeled orders represent each visible arrangement?

Solution

1. Fix a P in the first position. The remaining tiles are M, M, N, N, and P. 2. If all five remaining tiles were different, there would be \(5!\) orders. Swapping the two M's or the two N's does not change an arrangement. 3. Divide by the repeats: \(\frac{5!}{2!2!}=30\) distinct arrangements.

Answer

\(30\) arrangements.
Permutations with repeated elements 10
Five letter tiles spell EEEFG. Imagine temporarily labeling the three E tiles \(E_1,E_2,E_3\) so that all five tiles can be distinguished. There are \(5!\) labeled arrangements. Explain why this counts each visible letter arrangement more than once. How many distinct visible arrangements are there?

Hints

- Try replacing the labels \(E_1,E_2,E_3\) with ordinary E's. Which arrangements become identical? - How many ways can three labels be exchanged while leaving the visible word unchanged? - What correction should be made to the labeled count?

Solution

1. In any fixed visible arrangement, the three E tiles can exchange labels in \(3!\) ways without changing the letters shown. 2. The \(5!\) labeled arrangements therefore count every visible arrangement \(3!\) times. 3. Divide to obtain \(\frac{5!}{3!}=20\) distinct arrangements.

Answer

\(20\) arrangements. Each visible arrangement is counted \(3!=6\) times when the E tiles are labeled.
Permutations with repeated elements 11
Each complete path represents a row of three letter tiles. a) How many complete paths are shown? b) If the small labels are erased, how many different letter rows remain? Name them. c) Give two different paths that lead to the same letter row and explain why.
Figure for problem 561668

Hints

- Follow a branch from the start all the way to its last tile. - Which differences between paths would disappear if the small labels were removed? - Compare two paths that begin with different A tiles.

Solution

1. The tree shows six complete paths, one for each order of the three temporarily distinguishable tiles. 2. Erasing the small labels makes the two A tiles identical. The visible rows are AAB, ABA, and BAA, so there are three different rows. 3. For example, \(A_1\)–\(A_2\)–B and \(A_2\)–\(A_1\)–B are different paths but both become AAB when the small labels are erased. Every visible row is counted twice in the tree.

Answer

a) \(6\) paths b) \(3\) different rows: AAB, ABA, BAA c) For example, \(A_1\)–\(A_2\)–B and \(A_2\)–\(A_1\)–B both become AAB.
Permutations with repeated elements 12
Ms. Miller is arranging four binders on a shelf: two identical blue binders, one red binder, and one green binder. a) How many distinct arrangements are possible if the red binder must be at the far left? b) How many distinct arrangements are possible if a blue binder must be at the far left? c) Explain why the answers to parts a and b are different.

Hints

- After fixing the first binder, identify the binders that remain. - Does switching two identical binders create a new arrangement? - Compare a multiset with two identical objects to three distinct objects.

Solution

a) Fix the red binder at the far left. The remaining binders are blue, blue, and green, giving \(\frac{3!}{2!}=3\) distinct arrangements. b) Fix a blue binder at the far left. The remaining binders are blue, red, and green, all distinguishable, so there are \(3!=6\) arrangements. c) In part a, interchanging the two identical blue binders does not create a new arrangement. In part b, all three remaining binders are different.

Answer

a) \(3\) arrangements b) \(6\) arrangements c) In part a, two remaining binders are identical; in part b, all three remaining binders are distinct.
Permutations with repeated elements 13
Numbers are formed from the digit cards \(2,5,8,\) and \(8\). a) Use a tree diagram or organized list to determine how many distinct three-digit numbers can be formed from three of the cards. b) How many distinct four-digit numbers can be formed using all four cards? Compare the result with part a and explain the relationship.

Hints

- Begin with the possible hundreds digits \(2,5,\) and \(8\). - Remember that the two \(8\) cards are identical. - After forming a three-digit number, how many cards remain unused? - For part b, compare directly with part a or use the repeated-object permutation count.

Solution

a) The distinct three-digit numbers are \(258,285,288,528,582,588,825,828,852,858,882,\) and \(885\), for a total of \(12\). b) The number of distinct permutations of all four cards is \(\frac{4!}{2!}=12\). Each distinct three-digit arrangement leaves exactly one unused card, which can be appended to form a corresponding four-digit arrangement, giving a one-to-one correspondence.

Answer

a) \(12\) three-digit numbers b) \(12\) four-digit numbers. Each three-digit arrangement determines exactly one four-digit arrangement by appending the unused card.
Permutations with repeated elements 14
Three fair six-sided dice are rolled independently, and \(X\) is the sum of the results. A player claims that \(P(X=9)\) and \(P(X=10)\) must be equal because each sum can be written in exactly \(6\) ways as an unordered sum of three integers from \(1\) through \(6\). 1. Check the player's count by listing all unordered triples for sums \(9\) and \(10\). Write each triple in nondecreasing order. 2. Find \(P(X=9)\) and \(P(X=10)\) using the \(6^3\) equally likely ordered outcomes. 3. Explain why the number of unordered triples alone does not determine the probability of each sum.

Hints

- Determine how many arrangements a triple such as \((1,2,6)\) has. - Compare triples with three distinct entries, two equal entries, and three equal entries. - The equally likely elementary outcomes identify the result on each of the three distinguishable dice.

Solution

1. For sum \(9\), the unordered triples are \((1,2,6)\), \((1,3,5)\), \((1,4,4)\), \((2,2,5)\), \((2,3,4)\), and \((3,3,3)\). For sum \(10\), they are \((1,3,6)\), \((1,4,5)\), \((2,2,6)\), \((2,3,5)\), \((2,4,4)\), and \((3,3,4)\). Each sum has \(6\) unordered triples. 2. There are \(216\) equally likely ordered outcomes. For sum \(9\), the multiplicities give \(3\cdot6+2\cdot3+1=25\) outcomes, so \(P(X=9)=\frac{25}{216}\approx0.1157\). For sum \(10\), the multiplicities give \(3\cdot6+3\cdot3=27\) outcomes, so \(P(X=10)=\frac{27}{216}=0.125\). 3. Unordered triples are not equally likely: a triple with three distinct entries represents \(6\) ordered outcomes, one with two equal entries represents \(3\), and one with three equal entries represents \(1\). Thus the unordered count alone ignores different arrangement multiplicities.

Answer

1. Each sum has \(6\) unordered triples. 2. \(P(X=9)=\frac{25}{216}\approx0.1157\) and \(P(X=10)=\frac{27}{216}=0.125\) 3. The unordered triples represent different numbers of equally likely ordered outcomes, depending on whether entries repeat.
Permutations with repeated elements 15
Six students—Nina, Omar, Priya, Sofia, Theo, and Vera—either take the bus or walk to school. Each also brings lunch or buys it. Two take the bus and bring lunch, one takes the bus and buys lunch, one walks and brings lunch, and two walk and buy lunch. Use A, B, C, and D for those four groups, in the order listed. Write one possible six-letter group assignment in the student order Nina, Omar, Priya, Sofia, Theo, Vera. Explain why \(6!\) counts some letter assignments more than once. How many different assignments are possible?

Hints

- The four groups have fixed sizes, but the students assigned to them can change. - How often does each group letter appear in the six-position string? - Would exchanging two copies of the same group letter create a different assignment?

Solution

1. One possible six-letter assignment in the given student order is AABCDD. Each full assignment has two A's, one B, one C, and two D's. 2. Labeling the two A's and two D's separately would give \(6!\) arrangements. Swapping the two A's or the two D's leaves the group assignments unchanged. 3. Each different group assignment is counted \(2!\cdot2!\) times, so there are \(\frac{6!}{2!\cdot2!}=180\) assignments.

Answer

One possible assignment is AABCDD in the given student order. There are \(\frac{6!}{2!\cdot2!}=180\) different assignments; swapping identical group letters does not change an assignment.
Permutations with repeated elements 16
A string is formed from the symbols \(A,A,A,B,B,B,C,C\). a) How many distinct strings can be formed using all eight symbols? b) One of these distinct strings is selected uniformly at random. Find the probability that it begins with \(AA\).

Hints

- For the total count, account for every repeated symbol group. - In part b, impose the required first two symbols before counting what remains. - Compare the favorable distinct-string count with the total distinct-string count.

Solution

a) The total number of distinct strings is \(\frac{8!}{3!\,3!\,2!}=560\). b) If the first two positions are A's, the remaining six positions contain one A, three B's, and two C's. The number of favorable strings is \(\frac{6!}{1!\,3!\,2!}=60\). Therefore, the probability is \(\frac{60}{560}=\frac{3}{28}\).

Answer

a) \(560\) distinct strings b) \(\frac{3}{28}\approx0.1071\)
Permutations with repeated elements 17
A six-symbol string contains \(m\) identical copies of A. Every other symbol in the string is distinct from A and from each other. The string has exactly \(120\) distinct arrangements. Find \(m\).

Hints

- Start from the number of arrangements of six distinct positions, then account for swaps among identical A's. - Express the arrangement count in terms of the unknown multiplicity. - Look for a factorial value that matches the resulting denominator.

Solution

1. If \(m\) copies are identical, the number of distinct arrangements is \(\frac{6!}{m!}\). 2. Set \(\frac{6!}{m!}=120\). Since \(6!=720\), this gives \(m!=6\). 3. Because \(3!=6\), \(m=3\).

Answer

\(m=3\)
Permutations with repeated elements 18
Priya is counting distinct arrangements of the letters in BALLOON in which the two O’s are adjacent. Priya first counts all arrangements as \(\frac{7!}{2!\,2!}=1260\), then divides by \(2\) and claims there are \(630\) arrangements with adjacent O’s. Explain the error and find the correct number of arrangements.

Hints

- Compare the adjacency condition with the unrestricted arrangements. - Look for a way to enforce adjacency before counting rather than correcting afterward. - After the adjacency condition is built into the objects being arranged, identify any letters that still repeat.

Solution

1. Dividing the unrestricted count by \(2\) assumes that exactly half of all distinct arrangements have adjacent O’s, which is not justified. 2. Enforce the adjacency condition before counting by treating the two O’s together as one unit. The objects to arrange are the OO unit, B, A, L, L, and N: \(6\) objects with two identical L’s. 3. The correct count is \(\frac{6!}{2!}=360\).

Answer

Priya’s division by \(2\) is unjustified. The correct number of arrangements is \(360\).
Permutations with repeated elements 19
Arrange the letters A, A, A, B, B, C in a row. Identical letters cannot be distinguished. How many arrangements have no two A's next to each other? Explain your counting method.

Hints

- Try a smaller version with two A's. Which rows keep them apart? - What could you count first so that the remaining restriction becomes easier to handle? - Does the condition change how many positions are available for the A's?

Solution

1. Arrange the non-A letters B, B, C in \(\frac{3!}{2!}=3\) visible orders. 2. Every such order creates four gaps: before, between, and after these letters. To keep the A's apart, place each of the three identical A's in a different gap. 3. Choose three of the four gaps, giving \(\binom{4}{3}=4\) placements for every B, B, C order. 4. The total is \(3\cdot4=12\) distinct arrangements.

Answer

\(12\) arrangements.

All problems may be used, copied and printed free of charge for school and tutoring, including paid tutoring. Commercial adaptations as well as publication or redistribution on the internet are not permitted.