52334812
A box contains \(20\) tickets, including \(5\) winning tickets. Four tickets are drawn in sequence. Determine whether each procedure can be modeled as a binomial experiment.
a) Each ticket is replaced before the next draw.
b) Each ticket is not replaced before the next draw.
Briefly justify each answer.
Hints
- Compare the contents of the box before and after a draw.
- Compare the probability of winning on the first draw with the probability on a later draw.
- Recall the constant-probability and independence requirements for a binomial experiment.
Solution
1. With replacement, each draw has two outcomes, winning or not winning. The probability of a winning ticket remains \(p=\frac{5}{20}=0.25\), and the draws are independent. Therefore, part a can be modeled as a binomial experiment with \(n=4\).
2. Without replacement, the composition of the box changes after each draw. For example, after drawing a winning ticket first, the next winning probability is \(\frac{4}{19}\), not \(\frac{5}{20}\).
3. Therefore, part b is not binomial because the draws are dependent and the success probability is not constant.
Answer
a) Yes. Replacing each ticket keeps the winning probability constant at \(0.25\) and makes the draws independent.
b) No. Without replacement, the draws are dependent and the winning probability changes from draw to draw.
