53907412
A student obtains \(L=1\) in the ratio test and concludes that the series diverges. Explain the error.
Hints
- Recall all three ratio-test outcomes, including the equality case.
- Distinguish “the test is inconclusive” from “the series diverges.”
- Ask what additional method would be needed after a boundary result.
Solution
1. The ratio test proves absolute convergence when \(L<1\) and divergence when \(L>1\).
2. When \(L=1\), the test gives no conclusion.
3. Therefore the student’s conclusion is invalid, and another test is required.
Answer
The conclusion is invalid; \(L=1\) makes the ratio test inconclusive.
