The data are \(1.9,2.1,3.9,4.1,5.9,6.1,7.9,8.1\).
a) Find the histogram frequencies for \([0,2)\), \([2,4)\), \([4,6)\), \([6,8)\), and \([8,10)\).
b) Find the frequencies for \([1,3)\), \([3,5)\), \([5,7)\), and \([7,9)\).
c) Explain what the comparison shows about bin placement.
Hints
- Apply the endpoint convention separately to each set of intervals.
- Count every observation exactly once in each histogram.
- Compare the resulting bar patterns rather than only their totals.
Solution
1. For part a), the frequencies are \(1,2,2,2,1\).
2. For part b), the frequencies are \(2,2,2,2\).
3. The same raw data can produce visibly different bar patterns when bin boundaries shift, so histogram appearance depends partly on bin placement.
Answer
a) \(1,2,2,2,1\)
b) \(2,2,2,2\)
c) Shifting the bin boundaries changes the visible pattern even though the data do not change.