A supplier compares two packing plans.
Plan A combines \(4\) cartons with independent weights. Each carton has mean weight \(12\,\text{kg}\) and standard deviation \(2\,\text{kg}\).
Plan B combines \(2\) crates with independent weights. Each crate has mean weight \(24\,\text{kg}\) and standard deviation \(3\,\text{kg}\).
For each plan, find the mean and standard deviation of the total weight. Which plan has the more variable total weight? Give exact standard deviations and round any decimal approximations to two decimal places.
Hints
- Treat each plan as a sum of independent, identically distributed components.
- Compare the centers and spreads separately.
- Use standard deviation, not the number of containers, to decide which total is more variable.
Solution
1. Plan A has mean \(4(12)=48\,\text{kg}\) and standard deviation \(2\sqrt{4}=4\,\text{kg}\).
2. Plan B has mean \(2(24)=48\,\text{kg}\) and standard deviation \(3\sqrt{2}\approx4.24\,\text{kg}\).
3. The means are equal, but Plan B has the larger standard deviation, so its total weight is more variable.
Answer
Plan A: mean \(48\,\text{kg}\), standard deviation \(4\,\text{kg}\).
Plan B: mean \(48\,\text{kg}\), standard deviation \(3\sqrt{2}\,\text{kg}\approx4.24\,\text{kg}\).
Plan B has the more variable total weight.