A supplier considers two independent-packing plans.
Plan A combines \(4\) cartons, each with mean weight \(12\,\text{kg}\) and standard deviation \(2\,\text{kg}\).
Plan B combines \(2\) crates, each with mean weight \(24\,\text{kg}\) and standard deviation \(3\,\text{kg}\).
For each plan, find the mean and standard deviation of the total weight. Which plan has the more variable total weight?
Hints
- Treat each plan as a sum of independent, identically distributed components.
- Compare the centers and spreads separately.
- Use standard deviation, not the number of containers, to decide which total is more variable.
Solution
1. Plan A has mean \(4(12)=48\,\text{kg}\) and standard deviation \(2\sqrt{4}=4\,\text{kg}\).
2. Plan B has mean \(2(24)=48\,\text{kg}\) and standard deviation \(3\sqrt{2}\approx4.24\,\text{kg}\).
3. The means are equal, but Plan B has the larger standard deviation, so its total weight is more variable.
Answer
Plan A: mean \(48\,\text{kg}\), standard deviation \(4\,\text{kg}\).
Plan B: mean \(48\,\text{kg}\), standard deviation \(3\sqrt{2}\approx4.24\,\text{kg}\).
Plan B has the more variable total weight.