54751112
Three random-sampling situations are described.
a) A sample of size \(5\) from a strongly right-skewed population.
b) A sample of size \(80\) from a strongly right-skewed population with finite standard deviation.
c) A sample of size \(5\) from a normal population.
For which situations is the distribution of the sample mean reasonably modeled as normal? Distinguish where the central limit theorem is being used from where it is not needed.
Hints
- Consider both the population shape and the sample size.
- Separate an approximate result caused by averaging from an exact result inherited from the population.
- Strong skewness matters more when only a few observations are averaged.
Solution
1. In a), the small sample does not provide enough averaging to overcome strong skewness, so a normal model is not justified from the information given.
2. In b), the large sample makes the sample mean approximately normal by the central limit theorem.
3. In c), the sample mean is normal because the population itself is normal; the central limit theorem is not needed.
Answer
a) A normal model is not justified from the information given.
b) The sample mean is reasonably modeled as normal by the central limit theorem.
c) The sample mean is normal because the population is normal; the central limit theorem is not needed.
