54837712
Three populations have proportions \(p=0.10\), \(p=0.50\), and \(p=0.90\). Each population contains at least \(3000\) members. From each population, a random sample of size \(300\) is taken and the sample proportion is recorded.
a) Find the standard deviation of each sampling distribution.
b) Which sampling distribution is most variable?
c) Explain why the distributions for \(p=0.10\) and \(p=0.90\) have the same standard deviation.
Hints
- Keep the sample size fixed and compare the part of the variability expression that changes.
- Proportions equally far from \(0.50\) have a useful symmetry.
- Check which population gives the most balanced split between the two outcomes.
Solution
1. For \(p=0.10\), \(\sigma_{\hat p}=\sqrt{\frac{0.10(0.90)}{300}}\approx 0.0173\).
2. For \(p=0.50\), \(\sigma_{\hat p}=\sqrt{\frac{0.50(0.50)}{300}}\approx 0.0289\).
3. For \(p=0.90\), \(\sigma_{\hat p}=\sqrt{\frac{0.90(0.10)}{300}}\approx 0.0173\).
4. The \(p=0.50\) distribution is most variable because \(p(1-p)\) is largest at \(p=0.50\).
5. The values \(0.10(0.90)\) and \(0.90(0.10)\) are equal, so the two standard deviations match.
Answer
a) Approximately \(0.0173\), \(0.0289\), and \(0.0173\), respectively.
b) The distribution with \(p=0.50\) is most variable.
c) The products \(p(1-p)\) are equal for complementary proportions \(0.10\) and \(0.90\).
