Aimathic
Login | English | Deutsch

Geometry math worksheets

Build your own math worksheets from 35,000+ problems for grades 3 to 12, from fractions to AP Calculus. Every problem comes with step-by-step solutions.

Reverse conditional probabilities

Learning goals

  • Distinguishes P(A|B) from P(B|A).
  • Computes reverse conditional probabilities from two-way tables or tree diagrams.
  • Finds a conditional probability by dividing the joint probability by the conditioning probability.
  • Explains why reversing the conditioning generally changes the probability.

Click problems to add them to your worksheet.

Reverse conditional probabilities 1
Let \(A\) mean “a package came from Warehouse A” and \(D\) mean “the package was damaged.” Which conditional probability answers the question “Given that a package was damaged, what is the probability that it came from Warehouse A”: \(P(D\mid A)\) or \(P(A\mid D)\)? Explain how you know.

Hints

- Identify the information that is already known in the question. - In conditional-probability notation, where is the known condition written? - Compare the two questions represented by the two possible orders.

Solution

1. The phrase “given that a package was damaged” makes \(D\) the condition. 2. The conditioned event is written after the vertical bar, so the required probability is \(P(A\mid D)\). 3. \(P(D\mid A)\) asks the different, forward question of how often Warehouse A packages are damaged.

Answer

\(P(A\mid D)\), because \(D\) is the given condition.
Reverse conditional probabilities 2
Let \(C\) mean a customer used a coupon and \(B\) mean the customer bought a backpack. A classmate writes \(P(B\mid C)\) for “the chance a backpack buyer used a coupon.” Is the notation correct? Correct it and say what the classmate's expression actually means.

Hints

- Which event has already occurred for the people in the question? - Compare the groups named after the bar in the two expressions.

Solution

1. A backpack purchase is already known, so it goes after the bar. The requested probability is \(P(C\mid B)\). 2. The classmate wrote \(P(B\mid C)\), which means the chance of buying a backpack among people known to have used a coupon.

Answer

Incorrect. The requested expression is \(P(C\mid B)\). The classmate's \(P(B\mid C)\) conditions on coupon users instead.
Reverse conditional probabilities 3
At a bus terminal, \(12\) buses arrived late. Of these, \(9\) came from Route East. There were \(20\) Route East buses in total. A dispatcher wants the fraction of late buses that came from Route East. Should the fraction be \(\frac{9}{12}\) or \(\frac{9}{20}\)? Say what the other fraction describes.

Hints

- Which group does the phrase “of late buses” identify? - Which denominator represents that group?

Solution

1. The known group is the twelve buses that arrived late. Nine came from Route East, so the requested fraction is \(\frac{9}{12}=\frac{3}{4}\). 2. The other fraction, \(\frac{9}{20}\), is the share of Route East buses that arrived late.

Answer

\(\frac{9}{12}=\frac{3}{4}\). The fraction \(\frac{9}{20}\) describes late arrivals among Route East buses.
Reverse conditional probabilities 4
The table counts how often buses and trains arrive on time or late. <table><tr><th></th><th>On time</th><th>Delayed</th></tr><tr><th>Bus</th><td>13</td><td>5</td></tr><tr><th>Train</th><td>6</td><td>4</td></tr></table> An arrival is chosen at random from the delayed arrivals. Which two numbers from the table are needed to find \(P(\text{Train}\mid\text{Delayed})\)? State the numerator and denominator, then find the probability.

Hints

- Find the cell where Train and Delayed meet. - Which other arrivals satisfy the known condition “Delayed”?

Solution

1. The numerator is the \(4\) arrivals that were both trains and delayed. 2. The denominator is all delayed arrivals, \(5+4=9\). 3. Thus \(P(\text{Train}\mid\text{Delayed})=\frac{4}{9}\).

Answer

Numerator: \(4\). Denominator: \(9\). Probability: \(\frac{4}{9}\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 5
Students chose a poster color for an art project, then decided whether to display the poster. <table><tr><th></th><th>Displayed</th><th>Not displayed</th></tr><tr><th>Blue</th><td>7</td><td>3</td></tr><tr><th>Red</th><td>4</td><td>6</td></tr><tr><th>Green</th><td>9</td><td>1</td></tr></table> A displayed poster is chosen at random. What is the probability it is green? Explain why the denominator is not \(30\).

Hints

- Which posters can actually be selected? - Add only the counts in the relevant column. - Does the question allow an undisplayed poster to be chosen?

Solution

1. The displayed posters number \(7+4+9=20\). 2. Nine of those are green, so the probability is \(\frac{9}{20}\). 3. The full \(30\) posters include ten that were not displayed and therefore could not be chosen.

Answer

\(\frac{9}{20}\). Only the \(20\) displayed posters belong in the denominator.
Reverse conditional probabilities 6
A condition affects \(5\%\) of a population. A test is positive for \(90\%\) of people with the condition and for \(10\%\) of people without the condition. A person receives a positive result. Find the probability that the person has the condition.

Hints

- Add all complete paths that lead to a positive result. - What fraction of the positive-result probability comes from the condition group?

Solution

1. Let \(D\) be the event that the person has the condition. The true-positive path has probability \(P(D\cap +)=0.05\cdot 0.90=0.045\). 2. The false-positive path has probability \(P(D^c\cap +)=0.95\cdot 0.10=0.095\). 3. Thus, \(P(+)=0.045+0.095=0.14\). 4. Therefore, \(P(D\mid +)=\frac{0.045}{0.14}=\frac{9}{28}\approx 0.3214\).

Answer

\(P(D\mid +)=\frac{9}{28}\approx 0.3214\), or about \(32.14\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 7
A bus depot schedules \(40\) trips on Route X and \(60\) trips on Route Y during a week. Of the Route X trips, \(20\%\) are delayed. Of the Route Y trips, \(10\%\) are delayed. One delayed trip from that week is selected at random. Find \(P(\text{Route X}\mid\text{delayed})\). Explain why this probability is not the same as the given \(20\%\).

Hints

- Convert each route's forward delay rate into a delayed-trip count. - For the requested reverse conditional probability, what group must form the denominator? - Compare the event after the vertical bar in the requested probability with the event after the vertical bar in the given \(20\%\).

Solution

1. Route X has \(0.20\cdot40=8\) delayed trips. 2. Route Y has \(0.10\cdot60=6\) delayed trips, so there are \(8+6=14\) delayed trips altogether. 3. Conditioning on a delay means using those \(14\) delayed trips as the denominator. Thus, \(P(\text{Route X}\mid\text{delayed})=\frac{8}{14}=\frac{4}{7}\approx0.5714\). 4. The given \(20\%\) is \(P(\text{delayed}\mid\text{Route X})\), which conditions on Route X trips instead of delayed trips.

Answer

\(P(\text{Route X}\mid\text{delayed})=\frac{4}{7}\approx57.1\%\). The given \(20\%\) is the opposite conditional probability, \(P(\text{delayed}\mid\text{Route X})\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 8
A basketball coach records \(8\) starters and \(4\) reserves. Four starters and one reserve make a free throw. Let \(S\) mean “started the game” and \(F\) mean “made the free throw.” Find \(P(S\mid F)\) and \(P(F\mid S)\). Explain why they differ.

Hints

- How many players actually made a free throw? - How many players started the game? - Which of those groups is given in each conditional probability?

Solution

1. Five players made a free throw, four of whom were starters, so \(P(S\mid F)=\frac{4}{5}\). 2. There were eight starters, four of whom made the shot, so \(P(F\mid S)=\frac{4}{8}=\frac{1}{2}\). 3. The shared count is four in both fractions, but the given group changes when the condition is reversed.

Answer

\(P(S\mid F)=\frac{4}{5}\); \(P(F\mid S)=\frac{1}{2}\). The denominators count different groups.
Reverse conditional probabilities 9
A museum counts visitors by age and tour type. <table><tr><th></th><th>Guided</th><th>Self-guided</th></tr><tr><th>Teens</th><td>8</td><td>12</td></tr><tr><th>Adults</th><td>22</td><td>18</td></tr></table> a) Among guided-tour visitors, what fraction are teens? b) Among teen visitors, what fraction chose a guided tour? Explain why the answers differ.

Hints

- For part a), which column contains everyone who could be selected? - For part b), which row contains everyone who could be selected? - Compare the denominators you used.

Solution

1. The guided group has \(8+22=30\) visitors, including \(8\) teens. So a) is \(\frac{8}{30}=\frac{4}{15}\). 2. The teen group has \(8+12=20\) visitors, including \(8\) on guided tours. So b) is \(\frac{8}{20}=\frac{2}{5}\). 3. Each probability uses the same shared cell but a different total as its denominator.

Answer

a) \(\frac{4}{15}\). b) \(\frac{2}{5}\). The given group changes when the condition is reversed.
Reverse conditional probabilities 10
Two branches of a library offer morning study rooms. The tree gives the chance a randomly chosen room belongs to each branch and is available. If a room is available, what is the probability it belongs to Branch East?
Figure for problem 561013

Hints

- Which two paths end at Available? - Find the probability for both types of available room before changing the denominator. - Among available rooms, what fraction came from East?

Solution

1. Available rooms from East account for a path probability of \(0.4\cdot0.8=0.32\). 2. Available rooms from West account for \(0.6\cdot0.2=0.12\). 3. Given availability, the probability the room is from East is \(\frac{0.32}{0.32+0.12}=\frac{8}{11}\).

Answer

\(\frac{8}{11}\)
Reverse conditional probabilities 11
Events \(A\) and \(B\) satisfy \(P(A)=0.18\), \(P(B)=0.30\), and \(P(A\cap B)=0.09\). Find \(P(B\mid A)\) and \(P(A\mid B)\). Are the two conditional probabilities equal?

Hints

- Which outcomes remain possible if you know \(A\) happened? - What changes if you instead know \(B\) happened?

Solution

1. Condition on A: \(P(B\mid A)=\frac{0.09}{0.18}=0.50\). 2. Reverse the condition to B: \(P(A\mid B)=\frac{0.09}{0.30}=0.30\). 3. The numerators match, but the denominators do not, so the probabilities are unequal.

Answer

\(P(B\mid A)=0.50\); \(P(A\mid B)=0.30\). They are not equal.
Reverse conditional probabilities 12
For events \(R\) and \(S\), \(P(S\mid R)=0.60\), \(P(R)=0.25\), and \(P(S)=0.50\). Find \(P(R\mid S)\).

Hints

- First find the probability that both events occur. - Which probability belongs in the denominator after reversing the condition?

Solution

1. The shared-event probability is \(P(R\cap S)=P(S\mid R)P(R)=0.60\cdot0.25=0.15\). 2. Reverse the denominator: \(P(R\mid S)=\frac{0.15}{0.50}=0.30\).

Answer

\(P(R\mid S)=0.30\)
Reverse conditional probabilities 13
A mailroom put red stickers on \(9\) of \(10\) fragile packages and on \(18\) other packages. A package with a red sticker is selected at random. What fraction of red-sticker packages are fragile? Why is this much smaller than \(\frac{9}{10}\)?

Hints

- If you already know a package has a red sticker, which kinds of packages could it be? - What was already known when the \(\frac{9}{10}\) fraction was formed?

Solution

1. There are \(9+18=27\) packages with red stickers. 2. Nine of these are fragile, so the fraction is \(\frac{9}{27}=\frac{1}{3}\). 3. The fraction \(\frac{9}{10}\) uses fragile packages as the starting group. The fraction \(\frac{9}{27}\) uses all packages with red stickers.

Answer

\(\frac{1}{3}\). The fraction \(\frac{9}{10}\) refers to stickers among fragile packages, not fragile packages among stickered ones.
Reverse conditional probabilities 14
In a game tournament, \(10\) players wore blue shirts, and \(8\) of them won a prize. Altogether, \(40\) players won prizes. Liam says, “Since \(80\%\) of blue-shirted players won, \(80\%\) of the prize winners wore blue.” Explain the mistake and find the correct percentage of winners who wore blue.

Hints

- Which group do you know a randomly selected winner belongs to? - Does the denominator count blue-shirted players or prize winners?

Solution

1. Eight of the ten blue-shirted players won, so \(P(\text{winner}\mid\text{blue})=\frac{8}{10}=80\%\). 2. Eight of the forty prize winners wore blue, so \(P(\text{blue}\mid\text{winner})=\frac{8}{40}=20\%\). 3. Liam reversed which group he was comparing within.

Answer

\(20\%\). The \(80\%\) refers to winners among blue-shirted players, not blue-shirted players among winners.
Reverse conditional probabilities 15
A distribution center uses two scanners to process packages. Scanner A processes \(70\%\) of the packages, and Scanner B processes \(30\%\). Scanner A reads a package incorrectly with probability \(2\%\), while Scanner B reads a package incorrectly with probability \(5\%\). Let \(F\) be the event that a package is read incorrectly. a) Find the probability that a randomly selected package is read incorrectly. b) Given that a package was read incorrectly, find the probability that it was processed by Scanner A. c) Interpret \(\frac{0.30\cdot 0.95}{0.70\cdot 0.98+0.30\cdot 0.95}\) in context.

Hints

- Draw a tree beginning with the scanner used. - Add all complete paths that end in an incorrect reading. - In the fraction in part c, identify the joint event in the numerator and the conditioned event in the denominator. - Correct and incorrect readings are complementary events.

Solution

1. Add the two error paths: \(P(F)=0.70\cdot 0.02+0.30\cdot 0.05=0.014+0.015=0.029\). 2. The joint probability of Scanner A and an error is \(0.70\cdot 0.02=0.014\). Therefore, \(P(A\mid F)=\frac{0.014}{0.029}=\frac{14}{29}\approx 0.4828\). 3. In the given expression, \(0.30\cdot 0.95=P(B\cap F^c)\), and the denominator is \(P(F^c)\). Thus, the expression is \(P(B\mid F^c)\), the probability that a correctly read package was processed by Scanner B.

Answer

a) \(P(F)=0.029\), or \(2.9\%\). b) \(P(A\mid F)=\frac{14}{29}\approx 0.4828\), or about \(48.28\%\). c) The expression is the probability that a package was processed by Scanner B, given that it was read correctly.
Reverse conditional probabilities 16
A shipping company uses an automated scanner to check packages for damage. Historically, \(2\%\) of packages are damaged \((D)\). The scanner sounds an alarm \((S)\) for a damaged package with probability \(94\%\). For an undamaged package, it gives a false alarm with probability \(4\%\). a) Find the probability that the scanner sounds an alarm for a randomly selected package. b) Given that the scanner sounds an alarm, find the probability that the package is actually damaged. c) Given that the scanner does not sound an alarm, find the probability that the package is nevertheless damaged. d) Of \(200\) packages marked as damaged by the scanner, about how many would be expected to be undamaged?

Hints

- An alarm can occur through a true-positive path or a false-positive path. - Reverse conditional probabilities by comparing the relevant joint path with all paths in the conditioned group. - For part c, use the paths that end in no alarm. - In part d, first find the undamaged proportion among all alarmed packages.

Solution

1. Add the alarm paths: \(P(S)=0.02\cdot 0.94+0.98\cdot 0.04=0.0188+0.0392=0.058\). 2. \(P(D\mid S)=\frac{P(D\cap S)}{P(S)}=\frac{0.0188}{0.058}=\frac{47}{145}\approx 0.3241\). 3. The no-alarm probability is \(P(S^c)=1-0.058=0.942\). Also, \(P(D\cap S^c)=0.02\cdot 0.06=0.0012\). Thus, \(P(D\mid S^c)=\frac{0.0012}{0.942}=\frac{1}{785}\approx 0.001274\). 4. The undamaged proportion among alarmed packages is \(P(D^c\mid S)=\frac{0.0392}{0.058}=\frac{98}{145}\approx 0.6759\). The expected count is \(200\cdot\frac{98}{145}\approx 135.17\).

Answer

a) \(P(S)=0.058\), or \(5.8\%\). b) \(P(D\mid S)=\frac{47}{145}\approx 0.3241\), or about \(32.41\%\). c) \(P(D\mid S^c)\approx 0.001274\), or about \(0.1274\%\). d) About \(135\) packages.
Reverse conditional probabilities 17
A factory produces components on two machines, \(M_1\) and \(M_2\). Of \(4000\) inspected components, \(2500\) were made by \(M_1\). A total of \(110\) components were defective \((D)\), including \(50\) made by \(M_1\). All other components were acceptable \((A)\). 1. Display the data in a complete two-way table of counts. 2. Find the probabilities for a two-stage tree diagram that branches first by machine and then by quality. 3. One defective component is selected at random from all defective components. Find the probability that it was made by \(M_1\).

Hints

- Enter all given counts in the table before using row and column totals. - For a tree branch, divide the branch count by the total at the preceding node. - In part 3, the conditioned group consists only of defective components. - Distinguish \(P(D\mid M_1)\) from \(P(M_1\mid D)\).

Solution

1. The machine totals are \(n(M_1)=2500\) and \(n(M_2)=4000-2500=1500\). The quality totals are \(n(D)=110\) and \(n(A)=4000-110=3890\). 2. The inner counts are \(n(M_1\cap D)=50\), \(n(M_1\cap A)=2500-50=2450\), \(n(M_2\cap D)=110-50=60\), and \(n(M_2\cap A)=1500-60=1440\). 3. The first-stage probabilities are \(P(M_1)=\frac{2500}{4000}=0.625\) and \(P(M_2)=\frac{1500}{4000}=0.375\). 4. The second-stage probabilities are \(P(D\mid M_1)=\frac{50}{2500}=0.02\), \(P(A\mid M_1)=0.98\), \(P(D\mid M_2)=\frac{60}{1500}=0.04\), and \(P(A\mid M_2)=0.96\). 5. Reversing the condition, \(P(M_1\mid D)=\frac{50}{110}=\frac{5}{11}\approx 0.4545\).

Answer

1. <table> <tr><td></td><td>\(D\)</td><td>\(A\)</td><td>Total</td></tr> <tr><td>\(M_1\)</td><td>\(50\)</td><td>\(2450\)</td><td>\(2500\)</td></tr> <tr><td>\(M_2\)</td><td>\(60\)</td><td>\(1440\)</td><td>\(1500\)</td></tr> <tr><td>Total</td><td>\(110\)</td><td>\(3890\)</td><td>\(4000\)</td></tr> </table> 2. \(P(M_1)=0.625\), \(P(M_2)=0.375\), \(P(D\mid M_1)=0.02\), \(P(A\mid M_1)=0.98\), \(P(D\mid M_2)=0.04\), and \(P(A\mid M_2)=0.96\). 3. \(P(M_1\mid D)=\frac{5}{11}\approx 0.4545\), or about \(45.45\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 18
A medical laboratory studies a rapid test for a rare disease. Long-term data indicate that \(2\%\) of the population has the disease. The test has a sensitivity of \(98\%\) and a specificity of \(95\%\). a) Use a probability tree for the situation to find the probability that a randomly selected person receives a positive result. b) Given a positive result, find the probability that the person has the disease. c) Explain why the probabilities in this problem are based on empirical data rather than an equally likely outcomes model.

Hints

- Branch first by disease status and then by test result. - A positive result can occur on two different paths. - For part b, compare the true-positive path with all positive-result paths. - Consider whether disease status and test results are symmetric, equally likely outcomes.

Solution

1. Let \(D\) represent having the disease and \(T\) a positive result. Then \(P(D)=0.02\), \(P(D^c)=0.98\), \(P(T\mid D)=0.98\), and \(P(T\mid D^c)=1-0.95=0.05\). 2. Add the positive-result paths: \(P(T)=0.02\cdot 0.98+0.98\cdot 0.05=0.0196+0.049=0.0686\). 3. Reverse the condition: \(P(D\mid T)=\frac{0.0196}{0.0686}=\frac{2}{7}\approx 0.2857\). 4. The prevalence, sensitivity, and specificity come from observed long-run relative frequencies. The outcomes are not assumed to be equally likely, so an equally likely outcomes model does not apply.

Answer

a) \(P(T)=0.0686\), or \(6.86\%\). b) \(P(D\mid T)=\frac{2}{7}\approx 0.2857\), or about \(28.57\%\). c) The probabilities are empirical because they are estimated from observed population and test data, not from a set of equally likely outcomes.
Reverse conditional probabilities 19
A market study reports information about a new smartphone model, TechX, among young adults. Report A: “TechX has a \(35\%\) market share. Of all TechX users, \(70\%\) are younger than \(30\). Among users of other brands, \(40\%\) are younger than \(30\).” Report B: “Among respondents age \(30\) or older, TechX has a market share of about \(21.2\%\). Respondents younger than \(30\) make up \(50.5\%\) of the survey, and TechX has a \(48.5\%\) market share within that group.” Determine whether the statements in Report B are consistent with the data in Report A.

Hints

- Identify the marginal and conditional probabilities stated in Report A. - Use the two possible brands to find the total probability of being younger than \(30\). - Reverse each condition with the definition of conditional probability or Bayes' rule. - A tree diagram can organize the path probabilities.

Solution

1. Let \(T\) be the event that a respondent uses TechX, and let \(Y\) be the event that the respondent is younger than \(30\). Report A gives \(P(T)=0.35\), \(P(Y\mid T)=0.70\), and \(P(Y\mid T^c)=0.40\). 2. By the law of total probability, \(P(Y)=0.70\cdot 0.35+0.40\cdot 0.65=0.505\), which matches \(50.5\%\). 3. The younger-group market share is \(P(T\mid Y)=\frac{P(Y\mid T)P(T)}{P(Y)}=\frac{0.245}{0.505}\approx 0.4851\), which rounds to \(48.5\%\). 4. For respondents age \(30\) or older, \(P(T\mid Y^c)=\frac{P(Y^c\mid T)P(T)}{P(Y^c)}=\frac{0.30\cdot 0.35}{0.495}\approx 0.2121\), which rounds to \(21.2\%\). 5. All three values in Report B agree with Report A after rounding.

Answer

Yes. Report A implies that \(50.5\%\) of respondents are younger than \(30\), TechX has about \(48.5\%\) market share among younger respondents, and about \(21.2\%\) market share among respondents age \(30\) or older.
Reverse conditional probabilities 20
Among vehicle owners in a region, \(15\%\) own an electric vehicle. Of electric-vehicle owners, \(80\%\) live in a large city. Of owners who do not own an electric vehicle, \(55\%\) live in a large city. Among vehicle owners, find the chance of owning an electric vehicle for someone living in a large city and for someone living outside a large city. Give each chance to four decimal places. Is the first more than twice the second?

Hints

- Distinguish the chance of living in a city given an electric vehicle from the reverse conditional probability. - Combine the city-resident portions of electric and non-electric owners to get the total city group. - For the outside-city comparison, consider both complements before finding the new denominator.

Solution

1. Let \(E\) mean owning an electric vehicle and \(C\) mean living in a large city. Then \(P(E)=0.15\), \(P(C\mid E)=0.80\), and \(P(C\mid E^c)=0.55\). 2. The total chance of living in a large city is \(P(C)=0.80\cdot0.15+0.55\cdot0.85=0.5875\). 3. Among city residents, \(P(E\mid C)=\frac{0.80\cdot0.15}{0.5875}\approx0.2043\). 4. Outside large cities, \(P(E\mid C^c)=\frac{0.20\cdot0.15}{1-0.5875}\approx0.0727\). 5. The ratio of the two unrounded probabilities is about \(2.81\), so the first chance is more than twice the second.

Answer

\(P(E\mid C)\approx0.2043\) (\(20.43\%\)) and \(P(E\mid C^c)\approx0.0727\) (\(7.27\%\)). Yes, the first is about \(2.81\) times the second.
Reverse conditional probabilities 21
A regional transportation study classifies newly registered vehicles by power source and owner type. Let \(E\) represent an electric vehicle and \(G\) a vehicle registered to a business. The data show that: - \(20\%\) of all newly registered vehicles are electric; - \(60\%\) are registered to businesses; - among vehicles registered to businesses, \(25\%\) are electric. 1. Create a complete two-way table of relative frequencies. 2. Find the probability that a privately registered vehicle is electric. 3. To answer “What proportion of electric vehicles are registered to businesses?” directly from a tree diagram, should the tree branch first by \(E\) or first by \(G\)? Briefly explain.

Hints

- Use the given conditional percentage to find the business-and-electric intersection. - Complete the table by subtracting from row and column totals. - In part 3, identify the event after “of electric vehicles” as the condition. - A second-stage branch probability is conditioned on the first-stage event.

Solution

1. The business-and-electric cell is \(P(G\cap E)=P(G)P(E\mid G)=0.60\cdot 0.25=0.15\). 2. The remaining cells are \(P(G\cap E^c)=0.60-0.15=0.45\), \(P(G^c\cap E)=0.20-0.15=0.05\), and \(P(G^c\cap E^c)=0.40-0.05=0.35\). 3. \(P(E\mid G^c)=\frac{P(E\cap G^c)}{P(G^c)}=\frac{0.05}{0.40}=0.125\). 4. The requested proportion in part 3 is \(P(G\mid E)\). A tree that branches first by \(E\) displays this conditional probability on a second-stage branch from the \(E\) node.

Answer

1. <table><tr><td></td><td>\(E\)</td><td>\(E^c\)</td><td>Total</td></tr><tr><td>\(G\)</td><td>\(0.15\)</td><td>\(0.45\)</td><td>\(0.60\)</td></tr><tr><td>\(G^c\)</td><td>\(0.05\)</td><td>\(0.35\)</td><td>\(0.40\)</td></tr><tr><td>Total</td><td>\(0.20\)</td><td>\(0.80\)</td><td>\(1\)</td></tr></table> 2. \(P(E\mid G^c)=0.125\), or \(12.5\%\). 3. Branch first by \(E\), because \(P(G\mid E)\) is then a second-stage branch probability from the \(E\) node.
Reverse conditional probabilities 22
A study examines the relationship between high stress \((S)\) and poor sleep quality \((Q)\) among college students. The study finds that: - \(40\%\) of the students report high stress; - among students with high stress, \(75\%\) report poor sleep quality; - among students without high stress, \(20\%\) report poor sleep quality. 1. Create a two-way table of relative frequencies. 2. What percentage of all surveyed students report poor sleep quality? 3. A randomly selected student reports poor sleep quality. Find the probability that the student also reports high stress.

Hints

- Convert each conditional percentage into a joint relative frequency. - Complete each row by subtracting from its marginal probability. - In part 3, use students with poor sleep quality as the conditioned group. - Compare the requested reverse conditional with the given poor-sleep rate among high-stress students; they need not be equal.

Solution

1. The joint relative frequencies involving poor sleep are \(P(S\cap Q)=0.40\cdot 0.75=0.30\) and \(P(S^c\cap Q)=0.60\cdot 0.20=0.12\). 2. The other cells are \(P(S\cap Q^c)=0.40-0.30=0.10\) and \(P(S^c\cap Q^c)=0.60-0.12=0.48\). 3. The poor-sleep marginal probability is \(P(Q)=0.30+0.12=0.42\). 4. Reversing the condition, \(P(S\mid Q)=\frac{P(S\cap Q)}{P(Q)}=\frac{0.30}{0.42}=\frac{5}{7}\approx 0.7143\).

Answer

1. <table><tr><td></td><td>\(Q\)</td><td>\(Q^c\)</td><td>Total</td></tr><tr><td>\(S\)</td><td>\(0.30\)</td><td>\(0.10\)</td><td>\(0.40\)</td></tr><tr><td>\(S^c\)</td><td>\(0.12\)</td><td>\(0.48\)</td><td>\(0.60\)</td></tr><tr><td>Total</td><td>\(0.42\)</td><td>\(0.58\)</td><td>\(1\)</td></tr></table> 2. \(P(Q)=0.42\), or \(42\%\). 3. \(P(S\mid Q)=\frac{5}{7}\approx 0.7143\), or about \(71.43\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 23
At Harbor Point University, a surveyed group consists of master’s students and undergraduates. Master’s students make up \(42\%\) of the group, and the rest are undergraduates. The survey found that \(15\%\) of the master’s students use the university library daily, compared with \(25\%\) of the undergraduates. 1. A student who does not use the library daily is selected at random. Find the probability that the student is an undergraduate. 2. An undergraduate is selected at random. Find the probability that the student does not use the library daily.

Hints

- Identify which percentages describe subgroups. - Use complements to find the probabilities of not using the library daily. - Part 1 reverses the direction of the given condition. - In each part, identify the group named after “given that.”

Solution

1. Let \(M\) represent a master’s student, \(U\) an undergraduate, and \(L\) daily library use. Then \(P(M)=0.42\), \(P(U)=0.58\), \(P(L\mid M)=0.15\), and \(P(L\mid U)=0.25\). 2. The complementary conditional probabilities are \(P(L^c\mid M)=0.85\) and \(P(L^c\mid U)=0.75\). 3. The overall probability of not using the library daily is \(P(L^c)=0.42\cdot0.85+0.58\cdot0.75=0.357+0.435=0.792\). 4. Therefore, \(P(U\mid L^c)=\frac{0.58\cdot0.75}{0.792}=\frac{145}{264}\approx0.5492\). 5. The second probability is the direct branch value \(P(L^c\mid U)=0.75\).

Answer

1. \(P(U\mid L^c)=\frac{145}{264}\approx0.5492\), or about \(54.92\%\). 2. \(P(L^c\mid U)=0.75\), or \(75\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 24
At a company, \(35\%\) of employees work in field sales and the rest work in the office. Of the field-sales employees, \(80\%\) commute in a company car. Of the office employees, \(10\%\) commute in a company car. 1. An employee who does not commute in a company car is selected at random. Find the probability that the employee works in field sales. 2. A field-sales employee is selected at random. Find the probability that the employee does not commute in a company car.

Hints

- Translate each stated percentage into conditional probability notation. - Distinguish “field sales and no company car” from “field sales given no company car.” - A tree diagram or two-way table can organize the proportions. - Part 2 asks for the complement of a percentage given directly in the problem.

Solution

1. Let \(F\) mean field sales and \(C\) mean commuting in a company car. Then \(P(F)=0.35\), \(P(F^c)=0.65\), \(P(C\mid F)=0.80\), and \(P(C\mid F^c)=0.10\). 2. The complementary conditional probabilities are \(P(C^c\mid F)=0.20\) and \(P(C^c\mid F^c)=0.90\). 3. The total probability of not using a company car is \(P(C^c)=0.20\cdot 0.35+0.90\cdot 0.65=0.655\). 4. Therefore, \(P(F\mid C^c)=\frac{0.20\cdot 0.35}{0.655}=\frac{0.07}{0.655}\approx 0.1069\). 5. For part 2, \(P(C^c\mid F)=0.20\).

Answer

1. \(P(F\mid C^c)\approx 0.1069\), or about \(10.69\%\). 2. \(P(C^c\mid F)=0.20\), or \(20\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 25
The partial tree describes a screening test for a rare metabolic trait. Let \(T\) mean having the trait, \(+\) a positive result, and \(-\) a negative result. a) Complete all missing branch probabilities and find the probabilities of the four complete paths. b) If a person tests positive, what is the probability that the person has the trait?
Figure for problem 537449

Hints

- Every pair of outgoing branches from a node must total \(1\). - Multiply first-stage and second-stage probabilities for each complete path. - Among all positive outcomes, what portion belongs to people with the trait?

Solution

1. The missing probabilities are \(P(T^c)=0.95\), \(P(-\mid T)=0.05\), and \(P(-\mid T^c)=0.90\). 2. The four path probabilities are \(P(T\cap +)=0.05\cdot0.95=0.0475\), \(P(T\cap -)=0.05\cdot0.05=0.0025\), \(P(T^c\cap +)=0.95\cdot0.10=0.095\), and \(P(T^c\cap -)=0.95\cdot0.90=0.855\). 3. Positive results occur on two paths, giving \(P(+)=0.0475+0.095=0.1425\). 4. Among positive results, the trait path accounts for \(\frac{0.0475}{0.1425}=\frac{1}{3}\).

Answer

a) Missing branches: \(0.95\), \(0.05\), and \(0.90\). Path probabilities: \(P(T\cap +)=0.0475\), \(P(T\cap -)=0.0025\), \(P(T^c\cap +)=0.095\), and \(P(T^c\cap -)=0.855\). b) \(P(T\mid +)=\frac{1}{3}\approx33.33\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 26
A factory makes precision components on two machines. Machine \(M_1\) produces \(75\%\) of all components, and machine \(M_2\) produces the rest. The rejection rate is \(5\%\) for components from \(M_1\) and \(10\%\) for components from \(M_2\). Let \(R\) be the event that a component is rejected. a) Find \(P(R)\). b) A rejected component is selected at random. Find \(P(M_1\mid R)\). c) Explain why \(P(M_1\mid R)\) is not the same probability as \(P(R\mid M_1)\).

Hints

- A rejected component can come from either machine. - Find the probability of each machine-and-rejected path before reversing the condition. - In a conditional probability, the event after the vertical bar determines the reference group.

Solution

1. The two rejected paths have probabilities \(P(M_1\cap R)=0.75\cdot 0.05=0.0375\) and \(P(M_2\cap R)=0.25\cdot 0.10=0.025\). 2. Add the paths: \(P(R)=0.0375+0.025=0.0625\). 3. Reverse the condition: \(P(M_1\mid R)=\frac{P(M_1\cap R)}{P(R)}=\frac{0.0375}{0.0625}=0.60\). 4. \(P(R\mid M_1)=0.05\) conditions on all components from \(M_1\), whereas \(P(M_1\mid R)=0.60\) conditions only on rejected components. The denominators and questions are different.

Answer

a) \(P(R)=0.0625\), or \(6.25\%\). b) \(P(M_1\mid R)=0.60\), or \(60\%\). c) \(P(R\mid M_1)\) uses all \(M_1\) components as the conditioned group, while \(P(M_1\mid R)\) uses all rejected components as the conditioned group.
Reverse conditional probabilities 27
A city transportation study classifies commuters by primary mode, train \((T)\) or car \((C)\), and by satisfaction with daily travel time: satisfied \((S)\), neutral \((N)\), or dissatisfied \((D)\). Of the commuters, \(60\%\) use the train. Among train commuters, \(50\%\) are satisfied, \(30\%\) are neutral, and \(20\%\) are dissatisfied. Among car commuters, \(30\%\) are satisfied, \(40\%\) are neutral, and \(30\%\) are dissatisfied. a) Create a two-way probability table with transportation mode as the rows and satisfaction level as the columns. b) Find \(P(T\mid S)\) and interpret it in context. c) What percentage of dissatisfied commuters use a car?

Hints

- Each inner table cell combines one transportation mode with one satisfaction level. - Add down each column to find the total probability for that satisfaction level. - In each conditional probability, use the conditioned satisfaction group as the denominator.

Solution

1. Multiply along each mode-and-satisfaction combination: \(P(T\cap S)=0.60\cdot 0.50=0.30\), \(P(T\cap N)=0.60\cdot 0.30=0.18\), \(P(T\cap D)=0.60\cdot 0.20=0.12\), \(P(C\cap S)=0.40\cdot 0.30=0.12\), \(P(C\cap N)=0.40\cdot 0.40=0.16\), and \(P(C\cap D)=0.40\cdot 0.30=0.12\). 2. The column totals are \(P(S)=0.42\), \(P(N)=0.34\), and \(P(D)=0.24\). 3. \(P(T\mid S)=\frac{0.30}{0.42}=\frac{5}{7}\approx 0.7143\). Thus, about \(71.43\%\) of satisfied commuters use the train. 4. \(P(C\mid D)=\frac{0.12}{0.24}=0.50\).

Answer

a) <table><tr><td></td><td>\(S\)</td><td>\(N\)</td><td>\(D\)</td><td>Total</td></tr><tr><td>\(T\)</td><td>\(0.30\)</td><td>\(0.18\)</td><td>\(0.12\)</td><td>\(0.60\)</td></tr><tr><td>\(C\)</td><td>\(0.12\)</td><td>\(0.16\)</td><td>\(0.12\)</td><td>\(0.40\)</td></tr><tr><td>Total</td><td>\(0.42\)</td><td>\(0.34\)</td><td>\(0.24\)</td><td>\(1\)</td></tr></table> b) \(P(T\mid S)=\frac{5}{7}\approx 0.7143\). About \(71.43\%\) of satisfied commuters use the train. c) \(P(C\mid D)=0.50\), so \(50\%\) of dissatisfied commuters use a car.
Reverse conditional probabilities 28
The partial tree gives probabilities for a rapid medical test. Here \(K\) means having the disease, \(+\) means a positive test, and \(-\) means a negative test. a) Complete the missing branch probabilities. b) Find \(P(K\mid +)\), the chance that someone with a positive result has the disease.
Figure for problem 537471

Hints

- What must probabilities on branches leaving the same point add to? - Which paths lead to a positive result? - Among people with a positive test, which path includes having the disease?

Solution

1. The missing branches are \(P(K^c)=0.9\), \(P(-\mid K)=0.1\), and \(P(+\mid K^c)=0.2\). 2. The two positive-result paths have probabilities \(P(K\cap +)=0.1\cdot0.9=0.09\) and \(P(K^c\cap +)=0.9\cdot0.2=0.18\). 3. The total probability of a positive result is \(P(+)=0.09+0.18=0.27\). 4. Among positive results, the disease path has share \(P(K\mid +)=\frac{0.09}{0.27}=\frac{1}{3}\approx33.3\%\).

Answer

a) \(P(K^c)=0.9\), \(P(-\mid K)=0.1\), and \(P(+\mid K^c)=0.2\). b) \(P(K\mid +)=\frac{1}{3}\approx33.3\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 29
A company buys rechargeable batteries from two manufacturers. Event \(A\) means that a battery comes from Manufacturer 1, and event \(B\) means that the battery has especially high capacity. The two tree diagrams represent the same experiment. a) Use tree diagram a) to find \(P(B)\). b) Complete every missing branch probability in the reversed tree diagram b).
Figure for problem 537473

Hints

- Add all complete paths that end in \(B\). - The same joint probabilities appear in either ordering of the tree. - Divide a joint path probability by the new first-stage probability to find a reversed branch.

Solution

1. Add the two paths ending in \(B\): \(P(B)=0.30\cdot 0.60+0.70\cdot 0.10=0.18+0.07=0.25\). 2. Therefore, \(P(B^c)=0.75\). 3. Reverse the branches from \(B\): \(P(A\mid B)=\frac{0.18}{0.25}=0.72\) and \(P(A^c\mid B)=0.28\). 4. The joint probability \(P(A\cap B^c)=0.30\cdot 0.40=0.12\). Thus, \(P(A\mid B^c)=\frac{0.12}{0.75}=0.16\), and \(P(A^c\mid B^c)=0.84\).

Answer

a) \(P(B)=0.25\). b) First stage: \(P(B)=0.25\), \(P(B^c)=0.75\). After \(B\): \(P(A\mid B)=0.72\), \(P(A^c\mid B)=0.28\). After \(B^c\): \(P(A\mid B^c)=0.16\), \(P(A^c\mid B^c)=0.84\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 30
A factory tests its microchips before shipping. The partial tree shows the chances that a chip is defective \(D\) or working \(D^c\), and whether the test flags it \(T\). a) Complete the missing branch probabilities. b) Given that a chip is flagged, find the probability that it is actually defective. c) Among flagged chips, what proportion are working? Explain one reason the factory should consider this before discarding flagged chips.
Figure for problem 537475

Hints

- Complete each pair of branches so its probabilities add to \(1\). - Find both paths leading to a flagged chip; either defective or working chips may be flagged. - In each reverse probability, the denominator is the total chance of a flagged chip. - Consider what happens to working chips if every flagged chip is discarded.

Solution

1. Missing branches: \(P(D^c)=0.98\), \(P(T^c\mid D)=0.05\), and \(P(T^c\mid D^c)=0.98\). 2. The two flagged paths have probabilities \(0.02\cdot0.95=0.019\) and \(0.98\cdot0.02=0.0196\). Thus, \(P(T)=0.0386\). 3. Of all flagged chips, the defective share is \(P(D\mid T)=\frac{0.019}{0.0386}=\frac{95}{193}\approx0.4922\). 4. The working share among flagged chips is \(P(D^c\mid T)=\frac{0.0196}{0.0386}=\frac{98}{193}\approx0.5078\). Discarding all flagged chips would also discard many good chips; the factory could consider a second check.

Answer

a) \(P(D^c)=0.98\), \(P(T^c\mid D)=0.05\), and \(P(T^c\mid D^c)=0.98\). b) \(P(D\mid T)=\frac{95}{193}\approx49.22\%\). c) \(P(D^c\mid T)=\frac{98}{193}\approx50.78\%\). A second check could prevent good chips from being thrown away.
Reverse conditional probabilities 31
The partial tree represents a two-stage experiment with events \(A\) and \(B\). The value written at a terminal node is the probability of the whole path leading to that node, not a branch probability. 1. Complete the missing branch probabilities. 2. Find \(P(A\mid B)\) and \(P(A\mid B^c)\).
Figure for problem 537480

Hints

- Branch probabilities leaving the same node sum to \(1\). - A terminal path probability is the product of its edge probabilities; use the given whole-path value to recover a missing edge. - To reverse the condition, find all paths ending in the event after the vertical bar.

Solution

1. Since \(P(A)=0.40\), the missing first branch is \(P(A^c)=0.60\). 2. The terminal value gives \(P(A\cap B)=0.10\), so \(P(B\mid A)=\frac{0.10}{0.40}=0.25\), and \(P(B^c\mid A)=0.75\). 3. Since \(P(B^c\mid A^c)=0.30\), the other branch there is \(P(B\mid A^c)=0.70\). 4. The remaining joint probabilities are \(P(A\cap B^c)=0.40\cdot0.75=0.30\), \(P(A^c\cap B)=0.60\cdot0.70=0.42\), and \(P(A^c\cap B^c)=0.60\cdot0.30=0.18\). 5. Thus \(P(B)=0.10+0.42=0.52\) and \(P(B^c)=0.30+0.18=0.48\). 6. Reverse the conditions: \(P(A\mid B)=\frac{0.10}{0.52}=\frac{5}{26}\) and \(P(A\mid B^c)=\frac{0.30}{0.48}=0.625\).

Answer

1. Missing branches: \(P(A^c)=0.60\), \(P(B\mid A)=0.25\), \(P(B^c\mid A)=0.75\), and \(P(B\mid A^c)=0.70\). 2. \(P(A\mid B)=\frac{5}{26}\approx0.1923\), and \(P(A\mid B^c)=0.625\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 32
The partial tree describes a rapid test for a rare pollen allergy. Here \(A\) means having the allergy, \(+\) means a positive result, and \(-\) means a negative result. a) Complete the missing branch probabilities. b) Find \(P(-)\) and \(P(A\cap +)\). c) Explain in words what \(P(+\mid A)\) means. d) Given a positive result, find \(P(A\mid +)\).
Figure for problem 537484

Hints

- Every pair of branches leaving one node must add to \(1\). - Find all paths ending in a negative result and multiply along them. - A joint probability counts both conditions, but a conditional probability restricts the reference group. - For the reverse probability, use all positive results as the denominator.

Solution

1. The missing branch probabilities are \(P(A^c)=0.98\), \(P(-\mid A)=0.05\), and \(P(-\mid A^c)=0.96\). 2. The two negative paths give \(P(-)=0.02\cdot0.05+0.98\cdot0.96=0.001+0.9408=0.9418\). 3. The allergy-and-positive joint probability is \(P(A\cap +)=0.02\cdot0.95=0.019\). 4. The probability \(P(+\mid A)\) describes the positive-result rate among people who have the allergy, which is \(95\%\). 5. Positive results have probability \(P(+)=1-0.9418=0.0582\). Among them, the allergy path accounts for \(P(A\mid +)=\frac{0.019}{0.0582}=\frac{95}{291}\approx0.3265\).

Answer

a) \(P(A^c)=0.98\), \(P(-\mid A)=0.05\), and \(P(-\mid A^c)=0.96\). b) \(P(-)=0.9418\); \(P(A\cap +)=0.019\). c) Among people who have the allergy, \(95\%\) receive a positive result. d) \(P(A\mid +)=\frac{95}{291}\approx32.65\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 33
An electronics manufacturer tests components for defects. Let \(D\) mean defective and \(T\) mean a positive test result. The partial tree gives the probabilities. a) Complete the missing branches. b) Find the overall probability \(P(T)\). c) Given a positive test, find \(P(D\mid T)\). d) Give all six branch probabilities of a reversed tree that branches first by test result.
Figure for problem 537486

Hints

- The outgoing branch probabilities from each node must add to \(1\). - For the reverse tree, both old and new orders represent the same four joint outcomes. - Use the combined positive paths for the new positive-test first stage. - For negative results, repeat the process with the two paths ending in \(T^c\).

Solution

1. The missing probabilities are \(P(D^c)=0.97\), \(P(T^c\mid D)=0.04\), and \(P(T^c\mid D^c)=0.98\). 2. Add the two positive paths: \(P(T)=0.03\cdot0.96+0.97\cdot0.02=0.0288+0.0194=0.0482\). 3. Reverse the positive condition: \(P(D\mid T)=\frac{0.0288}{0.0482}=\frac{144}{241}\approx0.5975\). 4. The reversed first stage is \(P(T)=0.0482\) and \(P(T^c)=0.9518\). 5. After \(T\), the two branches are \(P(D\mid T)=\frac{144}{241}\) and \(P(D^c\mid T)=\frac{97}{241}\). 6. After \(T^c\), the two branches are \(P(D\mid T^c)=\frac{0.0012}{0.9518}=\frac{6}{4759}\) and \(P(D^c\mid T^c)=\frac{0.9506}{0.9518}=\frac{4753}{4759}\).

Answer

a) \(P(D^c)=0.97\), \(P(T^c\mid D)=0.04\), and \(P(T^c\mid D^c)=0.98\). b) \(P(T)=0.0482\), or \(4.82\%\). c) \(P(D\mid T)=\frac{144}{241}\approx59.75\%\). d) First stage: \(P(T)=0.0482\), \(P(T^c)=0.9518\). After \(T\): \(\frac{144}{241}\), \(\frac{97}{241}\). After \(T^c\): \(\frac{6}{4759}\), \(\frac{4753}{4759}\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 34
The two trees describe a survey of teenagers. Event \(L\) means regularly listening to podcasts, and event \(S\) means using a paid music-streaming service. Diagram a) gives the probabilities; diagram b) reverses the order of the events. a) Find \(P(S)\). b) Complete all missing branch probabilities in diagram b). c) Compare \(P(S\mid L)\) and \(P(L\mid S)\). Explain what each means.
Figure for problem 537490

Hints

- Find the four joint outcomes by multiplying along diagram a). - Add the paths ending in streaming to find the reversed tree's first-stage rates. - Each reverse branch is a joint probability divided by the appropriate new first-stage probability. - Identify which group comes after the vertical bar when interpreting the two conditional probabilities.

Solution

1. The four joint probabilities are \(P(L\cap S)=0.40\cdot0.70=0.28\), \(P(L\cap S^c)=0.40\cdot0.30=0.12\), \(P(L^c\cap S)=0.60\cdot0.30=0.18\), and \(P(L^c\cap S^c)=0.60\cdot0.70=0.42\). 2. Add the paths ending in \(S\): \(P(S)=0.28+0.18=0.46\), so \(P(S^c)=0.54\). 3. The reversed branches after \(S\) are \(P(L\mid S)=\frac{0.28}{0.46}=\frac{14}{23}\) and \(P(L^c\mid S)=\frac{9}{23}\). 4. After \(S^c\), the reversed branches are \(P(L\mid S^c)=\frac{0.12}{0.54}=\frac{2}{9}\) and \(P(L^c\mid S^c)=\frac{7}{9}\). 5. \(P(S\mid L)=0.70\) is the streaming share among podcast listeners, whereas \(P(L\mid S)=\frac{14}{23}\approx0.6087\) is the podcast-listening share among streaming subscribers.

Answer

a) \(P(S)=0.46\), or \(46\%\). b) First stage: \(P(S)=0.46\), \(P(S^c)=0.54\). After \(S\): \(P(L\mid S)=\frac{14}{23}\), \(P(L^c\mid S)=\frac{9}{23}\). After \(S^c\): \(P(L\mid S^c)=\frac{2}{9}\), \(P(L^c\mid S^c)=\frac{7}{9}\). c) \(P(S\mid L)=0.70\) is the streaming rate among podcast listeners; \(P(L\mid S)=\frac{14}{23}\approx0.6087\) is the podcast-listening rate among streaming subscribers.
Reverse conditional probabilities 35
A company manufactures electronic chips at two plants. Plant 1 \((P_1)\) produces \(60\%\) of the chips, and Plant 2 \((P_2)\) produces the rest. The defect rate is \(4\%\) at Plant 1 and \(7\%\) at Plant 2. a) Find the probability that a randomly selected chip is defective. b) Given that a chip is defective, find the probability that it was produced at Plant 1.

Hints

- Identify every plant-and-defective path. - Add the probabilities of those paths for part a. - For part b, divide the defective contribution from Plant 1 by the probability of all defective chips.

Solution

1. The branch probabilities are \(P(P_1)=0.60\), \(P(P_2)=0.40\), \(P(D\mid P_1)=0.04\), and \(P(D\mid P_2)=0.07\). 2. Add the defective paths: \(P(D)=0.60\cdot 0.04+0.40\cdot 0.07=0.024+0.028=0.052\). 3. The Plant 1 defective path has probability \(P(P_1\cap D)=0.024\). Therefore, \(P(P_1\mid D)=\frac{0.024}{0.052}=\frac{6}{13}\approx 0.4615\).

Answer

a) \(P(D)=0.052\), or \(5.2\%\). b) \(P(P_1\mid D)=\frac{6}{13}\approx 0.4615\), or about \(46.15\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 36
Suppose \(P(B)=0.30\), \(P(A\mid B)=0.80\), and \(P(A\mid B^c)=0.20\). Interpret \(P(A\mid B)=0.80\) in words, and find \(P(B\mid A)\).

Hints

- Which event forms the reference group in the first conditional probability? - Find the probabilities of both paths that end at \(A\).

Solution

1. The statement \(P(A\mid B)=0.80\) means that among outcomes in event \(B\), \(80\%\) are also in event \(A\). 2. The two paths ending in \(A\) have probabilities \(P(A\cap B)=0.30\cdot 0.80=0.24\) and \(P(A\cap B^c)=0.70\cdot 0.20=0.14\). 3. Therefore, \(P(A)=0.24+0.14=0.38\). 4. Reverse the condition: \(P(B\mid A)=\frac{P(A\cap B)}{P(A)}=\frac{0.24}{0.38}=\frac{12}{19}\approx 0.6316\).

Answer

\(P(A\mid B)=0.80\) means that \(80\%\) of the outcomes in \(B\) are also in \(A\). Also, \(P(B\mid A)=\frac{12}{19}\approx 0.6316\), or about \(63.16\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 37
Given \(P(A)=0.40\), \(P(B\mid A)=0.75\), and \(P(B\mid A^c)=0.25\), find \(P(A\mid B)\) and \(P(A\mid B^c)\).

Hints

- Find the four complete path probabilities first. - Then regroup the paths by the second-stage event.

Solution

1. The four joint probabilities are \(P(A\cap B)=0.40\cdot 0.75=0.30\), \(P(A\cap B^c)=0.40\cdot 0.25=0.10\), \(P(A^c\cap B)=0.60\cdot 0.25=0.15\), and \(P(A^c\cap B^c)=0.60\cdot 0.75=0.45\). 2. Since \(P(B)=0.30+0.15=0.45\), \(P(A\mid B)=\frac{0.30}{0.45}=\frac{2}{3}\). 3. Since \(P(B^c)=0.10+0.45=0.55\), \(P(A\mid B^c)=\frac{0.10}{0.55}=\frac{2}{11}\).

Answer

\(P(A\mid B)=\frac{2}{3}\), and \(P(A\mid B^c)=\frac{2}{11}\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 38
Suppose \(P(A)=0.60\), \(P(B\mid A)=0.30\), and \(P(B\mid A^c)=0.20\). Jordan calculates \(P(A\mid B)\) by dividing \(P(A\cap B)\) by \(P(A)\). Identify the error and find the correct value of \(P(A\mid B)\).

Hints

- Which event becomes the restricted sample space after the condition is stated? - Add all complete paths that end in that event.

Solution

1. The two paths ending in \(B\) have probabilities \(P(A\cap B)=0.60\cdot 0.30=0.18\) and \(P(A^c\cap B)=0.40\cdot 0.20=0.08\). 2. Therefore, \(P(B)=0.18+0.08=0.26\). 3. The correct conditional probability is \(P(A\mid B)=\frac{P(A\cap B)}{P(B)}=\frac{0.18}{0.26}=\frac{9}{13}\approx 0.6923\). 4. Jordan used the wrong denominator. The denominator must represent the condition \(B\), not event \(A\).

Answer

Jordan used \(P(A)\) as the denominator instead of \(P(B)\). The correct value is \(P(A\mid B)=\frac{9}{13}\approx 0.6923\), or about \(69.23\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 39
A robotics club buys circuit boards from three shops. Lakeside supplies \(50\%\) of the boards, and \(1\%\) of its boards are defective. Bayview supplies \(30\%\), and \(3\%\) are defective. Summit supplies the rest, and \(5\%\) are defective. A board is selected at random and is defective. What is the probability that it came from Summit?

Hints

- What share of the boards came from the third shop? - A defective board could have come from any of the shops. How can you count each possible source? - Once a board is known to be defective, which group is the new total?

Solution

1. The shops' shares are \(0.50\), \(0.30\), and \(0.20\). 2. The probabilities of a defective board from Lakeside, Bayview, and Summit are \(0.50\cdot0.01=0.005\), \(0.30\cdot0.03=0.009\), and \(0.20\cdot0.05=0.010\). 3. The total probability of a defective board is \(0.005+0.009+0.010=0.024\). 4. The conditional probability for Summit is \(\frac{0.010}{0.024}=\frac{5}{12}\).

Answer

\(\frac{5}{12}\approx41.67\%\)
Reverse conditional probabilities 40
The tree diagram summarizes a survey of \(1200\) people by whether they regularly ride a bicycle and whether they usually wear a helmet. Complete the missing counts in the tree diagram and find \(P(\text{bicycle rider}\mid \text{helmet})\).
Figure for problem 537582

Hints

- Read the known counts from the tree before filling any blank. - Complete each branch so that its leaf counts add to the group count. - Then combine all respondents who usually wear a helmet into the conditioned group.

Solution

1. The number who do not regularly ride a bicycle is \(1200-450=750\). 2. The remaining missing counts are \(450-360=90\) bicycle riders without helmets and \(750-150=600\) nonriders without helmets. 3. The total number who usually wear a helmet is \(360+150=510\). 4. Therefore, \(P(\text{bicycle rider}\mid \text{helmet})=\frac{360}{510}=\frac{12}{17}\approx 0.7059\).

Answer

The missing counts are \(750\), \(90\), and \(600\). \(P(\text{bicycle rider}\mid \text{helmet})=\frac{12}{17}\approx 0.7059\), or about \(70.59\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 41
Tree diagram a) is given. Reconstruct tree diagram b), with \(D\) as the first-stage event.
Figure for problem 537584

Hints

- Read the three given probabilities from tree a) and calculate its four terminal probabilities. - Regroup those terminal probabilities by the event that will appear first in the new tree.

Solution

1. From tree a), the terminal probabilities are \(P(D\cap +)=0.2\cdot 0.6=0.12\) and \(P(D\cap -)=0.8\cdot 0.1=0.08\). 2. Therefore, \(P(D)=0.12+0.08=0.20\) and \(P(D^c)=0.80\). 3. After \(D\), \(P(+\mid D)=\frac{0.12}{0.20}=0.60\), so \(P(-\mid D)=0.40\). 4. Also, \(P(D^c\cap +)=0.20-0.12=0.08\). Thus, \(P(+\mid D^c)=\frac{0.08}{0.80}=0.10\), so \(P(-\mid D^c)=0.90\).

Answer

\(P(D)=0.20\), \(P(D^c)=0.80\); after \(D\): \(P(+\mid D)=0.60\), \(P(-\mid D)=0.40\); after \(D^c\): \(P(+\mid D^c)=0.10\), \(P(-\mid D^c)=0.90\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 42
Each student is in exactly one of two programs: music or athletics. Let \(M\) be the event that a student is in the music program and \(W\) the event that the student receives a school award. Thus, \(M^c\) represents athletics. The tree diagram gives the program proportions and the award rate within each program. a) Read \(P(W\mid M)\) from the tree. b) Given that a randomly selected student received an award, find \(P(M\mid W)\). c) Explain why the answers to parts a and b are different conditional probabilities.
Figure for problem 537586

Hints

- First identify which tree branch is the forward conditional probability in part a. - For part b, find every tree path that ends with an award. - The denominator for \(P(M\mid W)\) must include award recipients from both first-stage branches.

Solution

1. The tree gives \(P(W\mid M)=0.30\). 2. The music-and-award path has probability \(P(M\cap W)=0.40\cdot0.30=0.12\). 3. The nonmusic-and-award path has probability \(P(M^c\cap W)=0.60\cdot0.10=0.06\), so \(P(W)=0.12+0.06=0.18\). 4. Therefore, \(P(M\mid W)=\frac{0.12}{0.18}=\frac{2}{3}\approx0.6667\). 5. Part a conditions on music students, while part b conditions on award recipients, so their denominators are different groups.

Answer

a) \(P(W\mid M)=0.30\). b) \(P(M\mid W)=\frac{2}{3}\approx66.7\%\). c) Part a uses music students as the conditioned group; part b uses award recipients as the conditioned group.
Reverse conditional probabilities 43
Students use a learning platform either intensively or rarely. Of all students, \(40\%\) use it intensively and \(60\%\) use it rarely. The exam pass rate is \(85\%\) for intensive users and \(55\%\) for rare users. A randomly selected student passed the exam. Find \(P(\text{intensive use}\mid \text{passed})\), and evaluate the claim, “The platform causes students to pass.”

Hints

- Find the probability of each group-and-pass path. - Add those probabilities to find the overall pass probability. - Divide the intensive-use-and-pass probability by the overall pass probability. - Consider variables that could affect both platform use and exam performance.

Solution

1. The probability of intensive use and passing is \(0.40\cdot 0.85=0.34\). 2. The probability of rare use and passing is \(0.60\cdot 0.55=0.33\). 3. Therefore, the overall probability of passing is \(0.34+0.33=0.67\). 4. The reverse conditional probability is \(P(\text{intensive use}\mid \text{passed})=\frac{0.34}{0.67}=\frac{34}{67}\approx 0.5075\). 5. The different pass rates show an association, but the data do not establish causation. Motivation, prior achievement, study time, or other variables could influence both platform use and exam success.

Answer

\(P(\text{intensive use}\mid \text{passed})=\frac{34}{67}\approx 0.5075\), or about \(50.75\%\). The observed association does not prove that the platform caused students to pass.
Reverse conditional probabilities 44
An infection is present in \(10\%\) of the people tested. The test is positive for \(80\%\) of infected people and is falsely positive for \(10\%\) of uninfected people. Let \(I\) mean that a person is infected. 1) Find \(P(I\mid +)\). 2) Find \(P(I^c\mid -)\).

Hints

- Find the total probabilities of positive and negative results separately. - For each conditional probability, restrict attention to the corresponding test-result group. - Compare the relevant joint path with that new group total.

Solution

1. The total positive probability is \(P(+)=0.10\cdot0.80+0.90\cdot0.10=0.17\). Therefore, \(P(I\mid +)=\frac{0.08}{0.17}=\frac{8}{17}\approx0.4706\). 2. The total negative probability is \(P(-)=0.10\cdot0.20+0.90\cdot0.90=0.83\). Therefore, \(P(I^c\mid -)=\frac{0.81}{0.83}=\frac{81}{83}\approx0.9759\).

Answer

1) \(P(I\mid +)=\frac{8}{17}\approx47.06\%\). 2) \(P(I^c\mid -)=\frac{81}{83}\approx97.59\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 45
A condition affects \(20\%\) of a group. A test has sensitivity \(0.95\) and specificity \(0.90\). After a negative result, someone claims, “The condition has been ruled out.” Evaluate the claim and find the actual probability that the person has the condition.

Hints

- A negative result can occur for a person who has the condition. - Compare that path with all paths that end in a negative result.

Solution

1. The probability of having the condition and testing negative is \(0.20\cdot 0.05=0.01\). 2. The probability of not having the condition and testing negative is \(0.80\cdot 0.90=0.72\). 3. The total negative-result probability is \(0.01+0.72=0.73\). 4. Therefore, \(P(D\mid -)=\frac{0.01}{0.73}=\frac{1}{73}\approx 0.0137\). The condition is unlikely but not ruled out.

Answer

The claim is false. \(P(D\mid -)=\frac{1}{73}\approx 0.0137\), or about \(1.37\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 46
A school bus runs on three routes. The probability tree gives each route's share of buses and its chance of being late. A randomly chosen bus arrives late. What is the probability it took the South route?
Figure for problem 561014

Hints

- How many different paths end at Late? - What is the probability of reaching Late by each path? - Which part of all late buses came from South?

Solution

1. The North–Late path has probability \(0.50\cdot0.10=0.05\). 2. Central–Late contributes \(0.30\cdot0.20=0.06\), and South–Late contributes \(0.20\cdot0.40=0.08\). 3. The total late probability is \(0.05+0.06+0.08=0.19\). 4. Among late buses, the South share is \(\frac{0.08}{0.19}=\frac{8}{19}\).

Answer

\(\frac{8}{19}\)
Reverse conditional probabilities 47
The tree shows whether a concert has outdoor or indoor seating and whether it is canceled. The two outdoor branch labels are missing. Overall, \(18\%\) of concerts are canceled. a) Find both missing outdoor branch probabilities. b) If a concert is canceled, what is the probability it had outdoor seating?
Figure for problem 561015

Hints

- First find how much of the overall canceled group comes from indoor concerts. - What part must therefore come from outdoor concerts? - Does the requested final probability use all concerts or only canceled concerts as its whole?

Solution

1. Indoor canceled concerts account for \(0.8\cdot0.125=0.10\) of all concerts. 2. Outdoor cancellations must therefore account for \(0.18-0.10=0.08\). Because outdoor concerts make up \(0.2\) of the total, \(P(\text{Canceled}\mid\text{Outdoor})=\frac{0.08}{0.20}=0.40\). 3. The other outdoor branch is \(1-0.40=0.60\). 4. Among canceled concerts, the outdoor share is \(\frac{0.08}{0.18}=\frac{4}{9}\).

Answer

a) Outdoor → Canceled: \(0.40\); Outdoor → Held: \(0.60\). b) \(\frac{4}{9}\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 48
Two high schools have different numbers of varsity athletes. - At West High, \(20\) students are athletes and \(180\) are not. - At East High, \(100\) students are athletes and \(100\) are not. At each school, \(90\%\) of athletes and \(40\%\) of other students wear running shoes. a) Among students wearing running shoes at West High, what fraction are athletes? b) Find the same fraction at East High. Why are the answers different even though both schools have the same shoe-wearing rates within each group?

Hints

- In each school, find how many athletes and nonathletes wear running shoes. - The condition limits you to the students wearing those shoes. - Compare the starting numbers of athletes across the two schools.

Solution

1. At West High, \(0.90\cdot20=18\) athletes and \(0.40\cdot180=72\) other students wear running shoes. Of the \(90\) wearers, \(\frac{18}{90}=\frac{1}{5}\) are athletes. 2. At East High, \(0.90\cdot100=90\) athletes and \(0.40\cdot100=40\) other students wear running shoes. Of the \(130\) wearers, \(\frac{90}{130}=\frac{9}{13}\) are athletes. 3. Athletes make up different shares of the two schools, so they also make up different shares of the running-shoe wearers.

Answer

a) \(\frac{1}{5}\). b) \(\frac{9}{13}\). East High has a larger athlete share, although the within-group rates are the same.
Reverse conditional probabilities 49
A factory makes \(1000\) parts, including \(10\) with cracks. A sensor flags \(90\%\) of parts with cracks and \(10\%\) of parts without cracks. Maya claims, “Because the sensor flags \(90\%\) of cracked parts, \(90\%\) of flagged parts must be cracked.” What fraction of flagged parts actually have cracks? Explain why Maya is wrong.

Hints

- Before using the sensor rates, how many parts have cracks and how many do not? - How do the two sensor rates apply to these different groups? - Which parts are in the group Maya is making a claim about?

Solution

1. The sensor flags \(0.90\cdot10=9\) cracked parts. 2. There are \(1000-10=990\) uncracked parts. Of these, \(0.10\cdot990=99\) are flagged. 3. There are \(9+99=108\) flagged parts, including \(9\) cracked ones. So the fraction is \(\frac{9}{108}=\frac{1}{12}\). 4. Maya reversed the condition: the \(90\%\) rate is among cracked parts, not among all flagged parts.

Answer

\(\frac{1}{12}\). Maya uses the percentage flagged among cracked parts instead of the percentage cracked among flagged parts.
Reverse conditional probabilities 50
The table records bus arrivals. Altogether, \(25\) arrivals were delayed, and \(60\%\) of those delays occurred on Route B. <table><tr><th></th><th>On time</th><th>Delayed</th></tr><tr><th>Route A</th><td>30</td><td>?</td></tr><tr><th>Route B</th><td>20</td><td>?</td></tr></table> a) Fill in both missing counts. b) Now reverse the condition: among all Route B arrivals, what fraction were delayed?

Hints

- The \(60\%\) statement is about which group of arrivals? - Once you know one delayed count, how can you find the other? - Which arrivals are included when the condition is Route B rather than Delayed?

Solution

1. Route B accounts for \(0.60\cdot25=15\) of the delayed arrivals. The remaining \(25-15=10\) delayed arrivals belong to Route A. 2. Route B has \(20+15=35\) arrivals in total, of which \(15\) are delayed. 3. The reversed conditional probability is \(\frac{15}{35}=\frac{3}{7}\).

Answer

a) Route A: \(10\) delayed; Route B: \(15\) delayed. b) \(\frac{3}{7}\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 51
In a school basketball competition, \(25\) players were guards and \(35\) were forwards. Fifteen guards made at least one three-point shot. The number of forwards who made a three-pointer is not known. a) If \(10\) forwards made a three-pointer, what fraction of all the players who made one were guards? b) If \(25\) forwards made a three-pointer, what would that fraction be? c) Explain why knowing that \(15\) of \(25\) guards made a three-pointer is not enough to answer the question without information about forwards.

Hints

- For each case, who belongs to the group of players who made a three-pointer? - What stays the same between the two cases, and what changes? - Can a single guard-only fraction determine the share among all successful shooters?

Solution

1. If \(10\) forwards made one, the group of players who made a three-pointer has \(15+10=25\) people. The guard fraction is \(\frac{15}{25}=\frac{3}{5}\). 2. If \(25\) forwards made one, that group has \(15+25=40\) people. The guard fraction is \(\frac{15}{40}=\frac{3}{8}\). 3. Both situations agree that \(15\) of \(25\) guards made one, but the reverse fraction changes because the number of successful forwards changes.

Answer

a) \(\frac{3}{5}\). b) \(\frac{3}{8}\). c) The number of forwards who made a three-pointer changes how many successful players could be selected. The guard-only fraction does not determine the reverse fraction.
Reverse conditional probabilities 52
An online store ships \(40\) mugs, \(30\) notebooks, and \(30\) tote bags. Customers return \(20\%\) of the mugs, \(30\%\) of the notebooks, and \(10\%\) of the tote bags. a) How many products of each kind are returned? b) If one returned product is chosen at random, what is the probability it is a notebook? Why isn't this the same as the fraction of shipped products that were notebooks?

Hints

- Are the return rates percentages of shipped products or of all returns? - Could a product type with fewer shipments have more returns than another type? - When choosing a returned product, which products could be selected? - Would the different return rates preserve the original mix of shipped products?

Solution

1. There are \(0.20\cdot40=8\) mug returns, \(0.30\cdot30=9\) notebook returns, and \(0.10\cdot30=3\) tote-bag returns. 2. Of the \(8+9+3=20\) returns, \(9\) are notebooks. Thus \(P(\text{notebook}\mid\text{returned})=\frac{9}{20}\). 3. Among all shipped products the notebook share was \(\frac{30}{100}=\frac{3}{10}\), but returned products are not distributed in the same proportions because the return rates differ.

Answer

a) \(8\) mugs, \(9\) notebooks, and \(3\) tote bags. b) \(\frac{9}{20}\). Among shipments the notebook fraction was \(\frac{3}{10}\); notebook returns make up a larger share because return rates differ.
Reverse conditional probabilities 53
Two events \(A\) and \(B\) satisfy \(P(A\mid B)=\frac{3}{4}\), \(P(B\mid A)=\frac{1}{2}\), and \(P(B)=\frac{2}{5}\). Describe a possible bag-of-tokens model for these events. Find the smallest possible total number of tokens and the number of tokens that have only property \(A\), only property \(B\), both properties, or neither property.

Hints

- Use the definition of conditional probability to find the probability that both events occur. - How can the intersection and the other conditional probability be used to find \(P(A)\)? - Express all category probabilities with a common denominator, then check whether the resulting counts can be reduced.

Solution

1. Find the intersection: \(P(A\cap B)=P(A\mid B)P(B)=\frac{3}{4}\cdot\frac{2}{5}=\frac{3}{10}\). 2. Use \(P(B\mid A)=\frac{P(A\cap B)}{P(A)}\): \(P(A)=\frac{3/10}{1/2}=\frac{3}{5}\). 3. Write the relevant probabilities with denominator \(10\): \(P(A)=\frac{6}{10}\), \(P(B)=\frac{4}{10}\), and \(P(A\cap B)=\frac{3}{10}\). Thus, \(10\) tokens can represent the probabilities. 4. Of the \(10\) tokens, \(3\) have both properties. Then \(6-3=3\) have only property \(A\), \(4-3=1\) has only property \(B\), and \(10-(3+3+1)=3\) have neither property. 5. Because the four category counts \(3,3,1,3\) have no common factor greater than \(1\), \(10\) is the smallest possible total.

Answer

The smallest model has \(10\) tokens: \(3\) have both properties, \(3\) have only property \(A\), \(1\) has only property \(B\), and \(3\) have neither property.
Reverse conditional probabilities 54
A storage room has two boxes of LED bulbs. Box 1 contains \(10\) green, \(5\) red, and \(5\) blue bulbs. Box 2 contains \(8\) green, \(10\) red, and \(2\) blue bulbs. One box is selected at random. a) One bulb is selected from the chosen box and is red. Find the probability that it came from Box 2. b) Two bulbs are selected without replacement from the chosen box, and both are blue. Find the probability that they came from Box 1. c) Without calculating, explain how the probability in part a would change if Box 1 were selected with probability \(70\%\) instead of \(50\%\).

Hints

- Draw a tree beginning with the box selection. - For each observed result, identify every path that can produce it. - When selecting without replacement, update the number of bulbs after the first draw. - For part c, compare how the prior probabilities of the two boxes change.

Solution

1. Each box initially has probability \(0.50\). The red probabilities are \(P(R\mid B_1)=\frac{5}{20}=0.25\) and \(P(R\mid B_2)=\frac{10}{20}=0.50\). 2. The overall red probability is \(P(R)=0.50\cdot 0.25+0.50\cdot 0.50=0.375\). Thus, \(P(B_2\mid R)=\frac{0.50\cdot 0.50}{0.375}=\frac{2}{3}\). 3. The probabilities of selecting two blue bulbs are \(P(\text{two blue}\mid B_1)=\frac{5}{20}\cdot\frac{4}{19}=\frac{1}{19}\) and \(P(\text{two blue}\mid B_2)=\frac{2}{20}\cdot\frac{1}{19}=\frac{1}{190}\). 4. Therefore, \(P(B_1\mid\text{two blue})=\frac{0.50\cdot\frac{1}{19}}{0.50\cdot\frac{1}{19}+0.50\cdot\frac{1}{190}}=\frac{10}{11}\). 5. If Box 1 becomes more likely to be selected, Box 2 becomes less likely. A red bulb still favors Box 2 because its red rate is higher, but the lower prior probability for Box 2 reduces \(P(B_2\mid R)\).

Answer

a) \(P(B_2\mid R)=\frac{2}{3}\approx 0.6667\), or about \(66.67\%\). b) \(P(B_1\mid\text{two blue})=\frac{10}{11}\approx 0.9091\), or about \(90.91\%\). c) The probability would decrease because Box 2 would be selected less often before the red bulb is observed.
Reverse conditional probabilities 55
A company gives \(20{,}000\) employees a screening test for a rare allergic reaction. Let \(A\) be the event that an employee has the reaction, and let \(T\) be the event that the test is positive. Suppose \(P(A)=0.01\), \(P(T\mid A)=0.98\), and \(P(T\mid A^c)=0.03\). a) Find \(P(T)\). b) Find \(P(A\mid T)\) and interpret the result. c) Determine whether \(A\) and \(T\) are independent. d) Explain why a large proportion of the positive results come from employees who do not have the reaction.

Hints

- A tree diagram can show the two paths that lead to a positive result. - Add the probabilities of the true-positive and false-positive paths. - For independence, compare a conditional probability with the corresponding marginal probability. - Compare the numbers of true positives and false positives among \(20{,}000\) employees.

Solution

1. Use the law of total probability: \(P(T)=P(A)P(T\mid A)+P(A^c)P(T\mid A^c)=0.01\cdot 0.98+0.99\cdot 0.03=0.0395\). 2. The joint probability is \(P(A\cap T)=0.01\cdot 0.98=0.0098\). Therefore, \(P(A\mid T)=\frac{0.0098}{0.0395}=\frac{196}{790}\approx 0.2481\). About \(24.8\%\) of employees with a positive result actually have the reaction. 3. The events are not independent because \(P(T\mid A)=0.98\neq P(T)=0.0395\). 4. Among \(20{,}000\) employees, about \(200\) have the reaction, producing \(196\) true positive results. About \(19{,}800\) do not have the reaction, producing \(594\) false positive results. The group without the reaction is so large that its small false-positive rate creates more positive results than the much smaller group with the reaction.

Answer

a) \(P(T)=0.0395\), or \(3.95\%\). b) \(P(A\mid T)\approx 0.2481\). About \(24.8\%\) of employees with a positive result actually have the reaction. c) \(A\) and \(T\) are not independent. d) The reaction has a very low base rate. The \(3\%\) false-positive rate is applied to the much larger group of employees without the reaction.
Reverse conditional probabilities 56
A researcher is deciding whether a coin is fair, with \(P(H)=0.50\), or biased toward heads, with \(P(H)=0.80\). Before any flips, the researcher considers the two hypotheses equally likely. The coin is flipped three times, producing heads, heads, tails. Find the probability that the coin is biased after each flip. How does the third flip change the assessment compared with the second flip?

Hints

- Compare how likely each observed result is under the two coin hypotheses. - Update the relative weights of the hypotheses after each flip. - A result that is less likely under one hypothesis should reduce that hypothesis's posterior probability.

Solution

1. Let \(F\) be the fair-coin hypothesis and \(G\) the biased-coin hypothesis. Initially, \(P(F)=P(G)=0.50\). 2. After one head, \(P(G\mid H)=\frac{0.50\cdot 0.80}{0.50\cdot 0.80+0.50\cdot 0.50}=\frac{8}{13}\approx 0.6154\). 3. After two heads, \(P(G\mid HH)=\frac{0.50(0.80)^2}{0.50(0.80)^2+0.50(0.50)^2}=\frac{64}{89}\approx 0.7191\). 4. After heads, heads, tails, \(P(G\mid HHT)=\frac{0.50(0.80)^2(0.20)}{0.50(0.80)^2(0.20)+0.50(0.50)^2(0.50)}=\frac{128}{253}\approx 0.5059\). 5. The tail is more likely under the fair-coin hypothesis than under the biased-coin hypothesis, so it reduces the posterior probability of the biased coin from about \(71.91\%\) to about \(50.59\%\).

Answer

After the first flip: \(\frac{8}{13}\approx 0.6154\), or about \(61.54\%\). After the second flip: \(\frac{64}{89}\approx 0.7191\), or about \(71.91\%\). After the third flip: \(\frac{128}{253}\approx 0.5059\), or about \(50.59\%\). The third flip sharply lowers the probability of the biased-coin hypothesis because tails is less likely for that coin.
Reverse conditional probabilities 57
A food-intolerance test gives a positive result for \(98\%\) of people who have the intolerance. It gives a negative result for \(96\%\) of people who do not have it. In Group A, \(1\%\) of people have the intolerance. In Group B, \(15\%\) have it. Both groups take the same test. a) In each group, what is the probability that someone with a positive result actually has the intolerance? Round to two decimal places as a percent. b) Why are the answers so different if the test works the same way for everyone?

Hints

- How often does a person without the intolerance receive a positive result? - Imagine each group contains the same large number of people. How many in each group would have the intolerance? - In each group, who could receive a positive result?

Solution

1. Let \(I\) mean having the intolerance and \(T\) a positive result. In both groups, the false-positive rate is \(P(T\mid I^c)=1-0.96=0.04\). 2. For Group A, \(P(T)=0.01\cdot0.98+0.99\cdot0.04=0.0494\). Thus, \(P(I\mid T)=\frac{0.0098}{0.0494}\approx0.1984\). 3. For Group B, \(P(T)=0.15\cdot0.98+0.85\cdot0.04=0.181\). Thus, \(P(I\mid T)=\frac{0.147}{0.181}\approx0.8122\). 4. A positive result is more likely to be a true positive in the group where the intolerance is more common. In Group A, the many people without the intolerance generate a larger share of positive results despite the same test characteristics.

Answer

a) Group A: \(19.84\%\). Group B: \(81.22\%\). b) The intolerance is more common in Group B. The same test therefore produces a larger share of positive results from people who actually have it.
Reverse conditional probabilities 58
A rare metabolic disease \(E\) affects about \(0.5\%\) of a population. A laboratory test \(T\) is positive for a person with the disease with probability \(0.98\). For a person without the disease, the test has a false-positive rate of \(0.03\). a) State \(P(T\mid E)\) and explain its meaning in context. b) Find \(P(E\cap T)\), the probability that a randomly selected person has the disease and tests positive. c) Find the probability that a person who tests positive actually has the disease. d) Use the probabilities to explain why \(E\) and \(T\) are dependent events.

Hints

- A conditional probability such as \(P(T\mid E)\) restricts attention to people in event \(E\). - Use the multiplication rule to find \(P(E\cap T)\). - For part c, divide the probability of a true positive by the probability of any positive result. - Independent events satisfy \(P(T\mid E)=P(T)\).

Solution

1. The sensitivity is \(P(T\mid E)=0.98\). This means that \(98\%\) of people who have the disease receive a positive result. 2. The joint probability is \(P(E\cap T)=P(E)P(T\mid E)=0.005\cdot 0.98=0.0049\), or \(0.49\%\). 3. The total probability of a positive result is \(P(T)=0.0049+0.995\cdot 0.03=0.03475\). 4. Therefore, \(P(E\mid T)=\frac{P(E\cap T)}{P(T)}=\frac{0.0049}{0.03475}\approx 0.1410\), or about \(14.1\%\). 5. If \(E\) and \(T\) were independent, \(P(T\mid E)\) would equal \(P(T)\). Since \(0.98\ne 0.03475\), the events are dependent.

Answer

a) \(P(T\mid E)=0.98\); among people with the disease, \(98\%\) test positive. b) \(P(E\cap T)=0.0049=0.49\%\). c) \(P(E\mid T)\approx 0.141=14.1\%\). d) The events are dependent because \(P(T\mid E)=0.98\ne P(T)=0.03475\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 59
An electronics retailer buys power adapters from two manufacturers. Manufacturer A supplies \(70\%\) of the inventory, and Manufacturer B supplies \(30\%\). Quality checks show that \(1\%\) of Manufacturer A's adapters are defective \((D)\), compared with \(4\%\) of Manufacturer B's adapters. a) Find the overall probability \(P(D)\) that a randomly selected adapter is defective. b) A customer returns a defective adapter. Find the probability that it was made by Manufacturer B. c) Management wants defect status to be independent of manufacturer. If Manufacturer A's defect rate remains \(1\%\), to what rate must Manufacturer B reduce its defect rate? Explain.

Hints

- Add the two manufacturer-and-defective paths. - For part b, determine what fraction of all defective adapters come from Manufacturer B. - Independence means that knowing the manufacturer does not change the defect probability.

Solution

1. Add the defective paths: \(P(D)=0.70\cdot 0.01+0.30\cdot 0.04=0.007+0.012=0.019\). 2. The joint probability for Manufacturer B and defective is \(P(B\cap D)=0.30\cdot 0.04=0.012\). Thus, \(P(B\mid D)=\frac{0.012}{0.019}=\frac{12}{19}\approx 0.6316\). 3. For defect status to be independent of manufacturer, the conditional defect rates for both manufacturers must equal the same overall defect rate. Since Manufacturer A's rate is fixed at \(1\%\), Manufacturer B's rate must also be \(1\%\).

Answer

a) \(P(D)=0.019\), or \(1.9\%\). b) \(P(B\mid D)=\frac{12}{19}\approx 0.6316\), or about \(63.16\%\). c) Manufacturer B must reduce its defect rate to \(1\%\). Equal conditional defect rates make defect status independent of manufacturer.
Reverse conditional probabilities 60
The partial tree shows whether an online order came from a returning customer \(R\) or another customer \(R^c\), and whether it uses express shipping \(E\). a) Complete the missing branch probabilities. b) What percentage of all orders use express shipping? c) Given that an order does not use express shipping, find \(P(R\mid E^c)\). d) Explain the difference between \(P(R\cap E)\) and \(P(E\mid R)\). Also interpret \(\frac{0.40\cdot0.15}{0.60\cdot0.80+0.40\cdot0.15}\) in this setting.
Figure for problem 537485

Hints

- Complete each pair of outgoing branches so the probabilities sum to \(1\). - Express orders occur along two complete paths; combine them. - For the nonexpress group, find the joint returning-customer path and divide by all nonexpress orders. - Decide which group is the denominator for each probability and for the displayed fraction.

Solution

1. Missing probabilities: \(P(R^c)=0.40\), \(P(E^c\mid R)=0.20\), and \(P(E^c\mid R^c)=0.85\). 2. Express-shipping paths total \(P(E)=0.60\cdot0.80+0.40\cdot0.15=0.54\). 3. Thus \(P(E^c)=0.46\) and \(P(R\cap E^c)=0.60\cdot0.20=0.12\), giving \(P(R\mid E^c)=\frac{0.12}{0.46}=\frac{6}{23}\). 4. The joint \(P(R\cap E)\) is the portion of all orders that are both returning-customer and express orders. The conditional \(P(E\mid R)\) is the express share among returning-customer orders. 5. The numerator of the fraction is \(P(R^c\cap E)\), while its denominator is \(P(E)\). Therefore, it is \(P(R^c\mid E)\), the proportion of express orders from other customers.

Answer

a) \(P(R^c)=0.40\), \(P(E^c\mid R)=0.20\), and \(P(E^c\mid R^c)=0.85\). b) \(54\%\). c) \(P(R\mid E^c)=\frac{6}{23}\approx26.09\%\). d) \(P(R\cap E)\) is relative to all orders; \(P(E\mid R)\) is relative only to returning-customer orders. The fraction represents \(P(R^c\mid E)\), the proportion of express orders placed by other customers.
Reverse conditional probabilities 61
A disease affects \(2\%\) of a population. A test is positive with probability \(0.95\) for a person with the disease and with probability \(0.02\) for a person without the disease. Conditional on disease status, the results of two tests are independent. A person tests positive first and negative second. What is the probability that the person has the disease?

Hints

- Follow the same positive-then-negative sequence from each initial disease-status group. - Divide the probability of the disease sequence by the total probability of both matching sequences.

Solution

1. The probability of having the disease and receiving the sequence positive, then negative is \(0.02\cdot 0.95\cdot 0.05=0.00095\). 2. The probability of not having the disease and receiving the same sequence is \(0.98\cdot 0.02\cdot 0.98=0.019208\). 3. The total probability of the observed sequence is \(0.00095+0.019208=0.020158\). 4. Therefore, \(P(\text{disease}\mid +,-)=\frac{0.00095}{0.020158}\approx 0.0471\).

Answer

Approximately \(4.71\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 62
In a long-term study at an outdoor pool, each observation is one person’s visit on one day. Of the observed visits, \(60\%\) occur on sunny days. On sunny-day visits, \(80\%\) of people buy ice cream and \(50\%\) get sunburned. On cloudy-day visits, the corresponding percentages are \(20\%\) and \(5\%\). Within each weather condition, assume that buying ice cream and getting sunburned are independent. Find \(P(\text{sunburn}\mid \text{ice cream})\). Explain why an observed association does not show that buying ice cream causes sunburn.

Hints

- Split the joint event by sunny and cloudy weather. - Find the total probability of buying ice cream across both weather conditions. - Look for a third variable that affects both observed events.

Solution

1. The probability of buying ice cream and getting sunburned is \(0.60\cdot 0.80\cdot 0.50+0.40\cdot 0.20\cdot 0.05=0.244\). 2. The total probability of buying ice cream is \(0.60\cdot 0.80+0.40\cdot 0.20=0.56\). 3. Therefore, \(P(\text{sunburn}\mid \text{ice cream})=\frac{0.244}{0.56}\approx 0.4357\), or about \(43.6\%\). 4. Weather affects both ice-cream purchases and sunburn risk. This common factor can create an association without ice cream causing sunburn.

Answer

\(P(\text{sunburn}\mid \text{ice cream})\approx 43.6\%\). Weather is a common influencing variable, so the association does not establish causation.
Reverse conditional probabilities 63
A rare trait occurs in \(0.3\%\) of a population. A screening method identifies \(90\%\) of people with the trait and flags \(2\%\) of people without the trait. Represent the situation with absolute frequencies for \(100{,}000\) people, and find the percentage of flagged people who actually have the trait.

Hints

- Start by converting the prevalence into a count out of \(100{,}000\). - Split both the trait and no-trait groups into flagged and not-flagged counts. - The conditioned group for the final percentage is all flagged people.

Solution

1. Of \(100{,}000\) people, \(100{,}000\cdot 0.003=300\) have the trait, so \(99{,}700\) do not. 2. Among the \(300\) with the trait, \(300\cdot 0.90=270\) are flagged and \(30\) are not flagged. 3. Among the \(99{,}700\) without the trait, \(99{,}700\cdot 0.02=1994\) are flagged and \(97{,}706\) are not flagged. 4. The total number flagged is \(270+1994=2264\). 5. The proportion of flagged people with the trait is \(\frac{270}{2264}=\frac{135}{1132}\approx 0.1193\), or about \(11.9\%\).

Answer

<table><tr><td></td><td>Flagged</td><td>Not flagged</td><td>Total</td></tr><tr><td>Trait</td><td>\(270\)</td><td>\(30\)</td><td>\(300\)</td></tr><tr><td>No trait</td><td>\(1994\)</td><td>\(97{,}706\)</td><td>\(99{,}700\)</td></tr><tr><td>Total</td><td>\(2264\)</td><td>\(97{,}736\)</td><td>\(100{,}000\)</td></tr></table> The percentage of flagged people who have the trait is \(\frac{270}{2264}\approx 11.9\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 64
A condition occurs with probability \(0.10\). A test has a false-positive rate of \(0.05\). Among all positive results, exactly \(50\%\) are true positives. Find the sensitivity of the test.

Hints

- Represent the unknown sensitivity with a variable. - Write the true-positive probability and the false-positive probability. - Express the proportion of true positives among all positive results as an equation.

Solution

1. Let \(s=P(+\mid D)\) be the sensitivity. The true-positive probability is \(0.10s\). 2. The false-positive probability is \(0.90\cdot 0.05=0.045\). 3. The given positive predictive value produces the equation \(\frac{0.10s}{0.10s+0.045}=0.50\). 4. Multiply both sides by the denominator: \(0.10s=0.50(0.10s+0.045)=0.05s+0.0225\). Thus, \(0.05s=0.0225\), so \(s=0.45\).

Answer

The sensitivity is \(0.45\), or \(45\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 65
A test has sensitivity \(0.90\) and false-positive rate \(0.05\). Given a positive result, the probability that a person has the condition is \(0.75\). Find the prevalence \(p\) of the condition in the tested group.

Hints

- Represent the unknown prevalence with a variable. - Write the true-positive and false-positive path probabilities in terms of that variable. - Express the proportion of true positives among all positive results as an equation.

Solution

1. Let \(D\) be the event that a person has the condition. The true-positive probability is \(0.90p\), and the false-positive probability is \(0.05(1-p)\). 2. The given posterior probability gives \(\frac{0.90p}{0.90p+0.05(1-p)}=0.75\). 3. Solving, \(0.90p=0.675p+0.0375(1-p)\), so \(0.2625p=0.0375\). 4. Therefore, \(p=\frac{1}{7}\approx 0.1429\).

Answer

\(p=\frac{1}{7}\approx 0.1429\), or about \(14.29\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 66
In a tested group, \(20\%\) of people have a condition. A test has sensitivity \(0.85\). Among all positive results, \(68\%\) are true positives. Find the false-positive rate.

Hints

- First find the proportion of the whole group that produces a true positive. - Represent the unknown positive rate among people without the condition with a variable. - Use the given proportion of true positives among all positive results.

Solution

1. The true-positive probability is \(0.20\cdot 0.85=0.17\). 2. Let \(f\) be the false-positive rate. The false-positive probability is \(0.80f\). 3. The given posterior probability produces \(\frac{0.17}{0.17+0.80f}=0.68\). 4. Solving, \(0.17=0.1156+0.544f\), so \(f=0.10\).

Answer

The false-positive rate is \(0.10\), or \(10\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 67
A disease affects \(2\%\) of a population. A test has sensitivity \(0.95\) and specificity \(0.98\). The same test is administered twice, with results conditionally independent given disease status. What is the probability that a person has the disease after two positive results?

Hints

- Follow the two-positive sequence from each initial disease-status group. - Divide the probability of the disease sequence by the total probability of both matching sequences.

Solution

1. The probability of having the disease and testing positive twice is \(0.02\cdot 0.95^2=0.01805\). 2. The false-positive rate is \(1-0.98=0.02\). The probability of not having the disease and testing positive twice is \(0.98\cdot 0.02^2=0.000392\). 3. The total probability of two positive results is \(0.01805+0.000392=0.018442\). 4. Therefore, \(P(\text{disease}\mid +,+)=\frac{0.01805}{0.018442}\approx 0.9787\).

Answer

Approximately \(97.9\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 68
A disease affects \(10\%\) of a group. Test A has sensitivity \(0.9\) and false-positive rate \(0.05\). Test B has sensitivity \(0.8\) and false-positive rate \(0.1\). Conditional on disease status, the tests are independent. Find the probability that a person has the disease after both tests are positive.

Hints

- Follow the two-positive sequence from each initial disease-status group. - The two test stages use different conditional probabilities. - Compare the disease-and-two-positive path with all paths producing two positive results.

Solution

1. The probability of having the disease and testing positive on both tests is \(0.10\cdot 0.90\cdot 0.80=0.072\). 2. The probability of not having the disease and testing positive on both tests is \(0.90\cdot 0.05\cdot 0.10=0.0045\). 3. The total probability of two positive results is \(0.072+0.0045=0.0765\). 4. Therefore, \(P(\text{disease}\mid A+,B+)=\frac{0.072}{0.0765}=\frac{16}{17}\approx 0.9412\).

Answer

\(\frac{16}{17}\approx 94.1\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 69
In an athletic program, \(2\%\) of participants use a banned substance. A test is positive for \(99\%\) of participants who use the substance and for \(3\%\) of participants who do not. A participant tests positive. Evaluate the statement: “There is a \(99\%\) probability that the participant used a banned substance.”

Hints

- Do not confuse the positive rate among users with the user rate among positive results. - Include false-positive results from the much larger group that does not use the substance.

Solution

1. Let \(D\) be the event that the participant used a banned substance. The true-positive probability is \(0.02\cdot 0.99=0.0198\). 2. The false-positive probability is \(0.98\cdot 0.03=0.0294\). 3. The total positive probability is \(0.0198+0.0294=0.0492\). 4. Therefore, \(P(D\mid +)=\frac{0.0198}{0.0492}=\frac{33}{82}\approx 0.4024\). The statement confuses sensitivity, \(P(+\mid D)\), with the reverse conditional probability \(P(D\mid +)\).

Answer

The statement is false. The probability is \(P(D\mid +)=\frac{33}{82}\approx 0.4024\), or about \(40.24\%\).
Reverse conditional probabilities 70
Two screening programs are used in a population where the condition prevalence is \(1\%\). Program A has sensitivity \(0.95\) and false-positive rate \(0.01\). Program B has sensitivity \(0.99\) and false-positive rate \(0.03\). For which program is a positive result more reliable? Support your answer with conditional probabilities.

Hints

- For each program, find the true-positive and false-positive probabilities. - Within all positive results, determine the proportion from the condition group. - Compare the two reverse conditional probabilities rather than the sensitivities alone.

Solution

1. For Program A, the true-positive probability is \(0.01\cdot 0.95=0.0095\), and the false-positive probability is \(0.99\cdot 0.01=0.0099\). Thus, \(P(D\mid +)=\frac{0.0095}{0.0095+0.0099}\approx 0.4897\). 2. For Program B, the true-positive probability is \(0.01\cdot 0.99=0.0099\), and the false-positive probability is \(0.99\cdot 0.03=0.0297\). Thus, \(P(D\mid +)=\frac{0.0099}{0.0099+0.0297}=0.25\). 3. A positive result is more reliable under Program A. Program B detects slightly more affected people but produces substantially more false positives.

Answer

Program A. Its positive predictive probability is about \(48.97\%\), compared with \(25\%\) for Program B.

All problems may be used, copied and printed free of charge for school and tutoring, including paid tutoring. Commercial adaptations as well as publication or redistribution on the internet are not permitted.