A server gives four different drinks to four guests but forgets who ordered which one. Every possible assignment is equally likely. Label each drink with the number of the guest who ordered it. Write an assignment as a list of the drink numbers served to guests \(1\) through \(4\).
a) List all permutations in which at least two guests receive the correct drink.
b) Find the theoretical probability that at least one guest receives the correct drink.
c) Explain without calculation why exactly three correct assignments are impossible.
Hints
- Represent each assignment as a permutation and compare each entry with its position.
- For part b, can you count the event directly or through another event that is easier to list?
- Consider what remains after three correct assignments.
Solution
1. The permutations with exactly two correct assignments are \((1,2,4,3)\), \((1,4,3,2)\), \((1,3,2,4)\), \((4,2,3,1)\), \((3,2,1,4)\), and \((2,1,3,4)\). The identity permutation \((1,2,3,4)\) has four correct assignments, so these seven permutations have at least two correct assignments.
2. For the complement event in part b, the no-correct permutations are \((2,1,4,3)\), \((2,3,4,1)\), \((2,4,1,3)\), \((3,1,4,2)\), \((3,4,1,2)\), \((3,4,2,1)\), \((4,1,2,3)\), \((4,3,1,2)\), and \((4,3,2,1)\). Thus there are \(9\) such permutations out of \(4!=24\).
3. Therefore, \(P(\text{at least one correct})=1-\frac{9}{24}=\frac{5}{8}=0.625\).
4. If three guests receive the correct drinks, the only remaining drink must belong to the only remaining guest, so all four assignments are correct.
Answer
a) \((1,2,4,3)\), \((1,4,3,2)\), \((1,3,2,4)\), \((4,2,3,1)\), \((3,2,1,4)\), \((2,1,3,4)\), \((1,2,3,4)\)
b) \(\frac{5}{8}=0.625\)
c) Three correct assignments force the fourth assignment to be correct.